6 ms·
Barnes and Noble and Microsoft End Nook Partnership
- megatroll 12y agoInteresting turn of events. I wonder how this will affect the e-reader industry.
- Someone1234 12y agoI never understood and still don't understand this partnership. So B&N has retail stores and Nook. Nook pre-Microsoft was Android based. They already had a Nook app coming out for Windows 8/RT. So when Microsoft invested a ton of money what was the ROI? Were they hoping to ship Nook devices with Windows RT on it? Or was there some other end-game? 300m is a lot of money and I don't understand what the pay off was even meant to be here.
- dataminded 12y agoMy rationalization of the investment is that B&N's partnership with publishers is/was tremendously valuable and would be very difficult/time consuming to build. It made more sense to partner with NOOK in order to secure access to that content than to try and build at Microsoft.
- msoad 12y agoNook was a company built by investments by B&N, Pearson and Microsoft. It was terribly executed but the idea was to help Microsoft complete their digital media catalog that was lacking books and help Pearson and B&N get into digital bookselling. Unfortunately almost none of those happened!
- super_sloth 12y agoThat's because this was never about Microsoft investing in the Nook. Microsoft's investment was really just a settlement with Barnes and Noble in everything other than name. Microsoft sued B&N (http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-12814018 http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-12814018) for infringing on the patents it's been collecting royalties from Android manufacturers for. B&N then counter-sued (http://www.phonearena.com/news/Barnes---Noble-countersues-Microsoft-over-Nook-Color-patents_id18532 http://www.phonearena.com/news/Barnes---Noble-countersues-Mi...). Once Microsoft invested in the Nook business, the whole thing got dropped. Makes you wonder if Microsoft were concerned that B&N actually putting up a fight might bring the whole of their lucrative Android licensing business in jeopardy.
- CapitalistCartr 12y agoAlso, Microsoft worries about Google, Android, Amazon cutting into their business. Like most large corporations, some investments are defensive. If Nook had gone better, it might have given MS a toehold in that camp.
- kyllo 12y agoYeah, I always saw it as a strategic "me too" product investment in response to Amazon Kindle.
- ChuckMcM 12y agoThis is my understanding as well. Most of the people Microsoft has sued for android patents have had some other part of the business that would go sideways if Microsoft withheld something (usually Windows) from them. B&N had no such weakness and so could see a patent suit all the way to the supreme court if it wanted, and since the Nook wasn't doing great anyway, the only 'downside' for B&N was that the Nook subbusiness went out of business. So very uneven on the risk/reward equation for Microsoft. They finesse it by "investing" and getting another "licensee" for their patents.
- tn13 12y agoBarnes and Noble should ideally end the entire Nook business as well. Every month I spend around $50 buying books at a physical B&N. I am just happy to buy their books on a standard Android App. Not sure what purpose the e-reader serves.
- CrazedGeek 12y agoThere's a good amount of people that prefer reading on E Ink screens over normal screens.
- checker 12y agoI'm not sure why you're writing off e-readers. I love my Nook. It's not as heavy as a book and its battery life is awesome. Also, The E-paper screen really is easier on my eyes and I can get "any" book I want instantly. It's somewhat analogous to the transition from CD player to iPod.
- lerchmo 12y agoWhy not Kindle?
- qzcx 12y agoWhy Kindle? Competition is good in any industry.
- fnordfnordfnord 12y agoNook isn't competition for Kindle. It's an also-ran.
- checker 12y agoAt the time Nook had the glow-light and Kindle didn't.
- brandonmenc 12y ago> Not sure what purpose the e-reader serves. Carrying around hundreds of books is the obvious killer feature.
- shmerl 12y agoSo will now MS require B&N to pay for patents again?
- rbanffy 12y agoWell... The patent list they use to extort Android makers is not a secret anymore, so there is no way B&N could threaten Microsoft with that. But I guess they now enjoy a perpetual license to those patents anyway.
- gdilla 12y agoThis never made sense. It may have been interesting if Microsoft had leveraged the B&N physical real estate to let users play with their new hardware, eg Surfaces, but that never happened. Nook continued to be the oft forgotten Android based ecosystem it always was.