3 ms·
Despite having done a lot of reading and researching about self publishing - and knowing people who've done it - I don't have any hard experience with it, so th
by petercooper 17y ago
Despite having done a lot of reading and researching about self publishing - and knowing people who've done it - I don't have any hard experience with it, so there are probably 101 HN readers with better answers, but..
I think a publisher like Apress can provide a lot of value. They have dedicated copyeditors, lawyers, and editors. They have design templates and workflows, ready to go. They can take imperfect content and make it sell. If you'd need to outsource many of these functions, perhaps a publisher is the way to go. There are a lot of "not so good" or poorly presented self published books out there that just don't sell.
Self publishing can work wonders, however, in situations where you're confident about the tasks involved. From my experience, the average HN reader or the average writers of stuff that HN links to are solid enough writers to not bother with independent editors - though you'd need to build up some willpower to be good at chopping ;-)
Technical reviewers would be more important, IMHO - and you can lean on your contacts/friends for this. This is one of the greatest assets a publisher provides. Last, if you have even a slight eye for design, you can pick up half reasonable layout and typesetting skills (in something like Indesign) in weeks.
Keep in mind, too, that Beginning Ruby is a 650 page book. Publishers seem to encourage long books, but I doubt you'd need to produce something so long - so making less money might not be such an issue. I think PeepCode does okay with its PDFs even at $9 a pop because most are 100 pages or fewer and don't take several months to produce.
Lastly, you need some way to get those sales. You either need the audience already (a popular blog, say) or have your marketing skills up to scratch. There's a lot I could write on this topic but this comment is getting a bit long, and I'll just end with.. consider doing it. If your topic is good and your writing solid, selling it shouldn't be the world's biggest problem to solve ;-)
- percept 17y agoWould a now-published author with an established Web presence have a better platform for successful self-publishing? ;)
- chromatic 17y agoYes, provided that the author is sufficiently good at editing, organizing thoughts, typesetting, copyediting, and marketing.
- tptacek 17y agoIt seems to me that you're giving up far more money to a publisher than a good copywriter and a good designer will cost. It's true though that you have to pay these expenses up front (although not until you've finished with the book itself, and even with the technical review --- at which point you know pretty well whether the copyeditor is worth the expense).
- chromatic 17y agoI agree, but I've also been a professional editor and know the extent to which editing can improve a manuscript. I personally won't work with a so-called traditional publisher again; I find their contract terms -- especially remuneration -- one-sided and unacceptable. I neglected to mention the value of distribution. The only way I can imagine working with a traditional publisher again is to increase the potential audience of a book through a dedicated sales and distribution channel -- but I'm not giving up 85% of gross revenue to do so.
- tptacek 17y agoDon't get me wrong: I'm sold on copyediting. I just don't think it's worth $100,000.
- matthewcford 17y agoPublishers seem to encourage long books, but I doubt you'd need to produce something so long. This is one of the reasons why I like PeepCode they don't encourage padding to fill a page count.