3 ms·
And intra-group licensing costs and royalties should also be disregarded as costs for tax purposes, since there's no real or opportunity cost to allowing one pa
by notahacker 12y ago
And intra-group licensing costs and royalties should also be disregarded as costs for tax purposes, since there's no real or opportunity cost to allowing one part of the group to use another's IP except for the cost savings that can be generated by shifting the tax burden.
- sokoloff 12y agoImagine a scenario where McDonalds corp has both company owned stores and franchisee-owned stores and that both are charged the same, substantial amount for the use of McDs trademarks. Should the McDs owned store be wildly more profitable in the eyes of the tax authorities? Suppose that the franchisee and the company store both use the McDs supply chain to buy ingredients. Are those costs "real enough to count"? If not, why not? If so, why aren't the trademarks "real enough"? If the trademarks don't count intra-group, what if the trademarks are only licensed (for $1) subject to the use of the company supply chain for ingredients? This serves a legitimate purpose of protecting the trademark and giving the customers a uniform experience at all stores, or it serves as an underhanded tax dodge, depending on which reporter is writing the article... I'm merely suggesting that trying to author precise legislation around this area is inherently a slippery slope and "intra group IP licenses are barred" isn't going to be perfectly effective. Lawmakers have a legitimately hard problem to solve and their "attackers" have a lot at stake to find/exploit intended or unintended loopholes.
- notahacker 12y agoSure, the McDs-owned store generates substantially more profit for its ultimate owner (the shareholders of MCD) than the franchise does for the franchisee, so I can't see any logical reason why McDonalds or its subsidiaries shouldn't pay more tax on that store than the franchisee. Of course there will still be loopholes. But the left hand of the business paying royalties to the (tax-advantaged) right falls under the heading of palpably ridiculous, especially when unlike the hypothetical McDs example the royalty rates are set by the tax planning division of an accountancy rather than the market.
- sokoloff 12y agoMy example was meant to consider only the tax generated as a result of the activities of the retail fast-food location. Of course corporate McDs will pay (the same) tax on the IP-related and/or supply chain profits generated by either store.