3 ms·
Thanks for some interesting insights! If it is money, then I would suggest they perhaps follow your advice and go with whoever gives them the biggest advance (
by petercooper 17y ago
Thanks for some interesting insights!
If it is money, then I would suggest they perhaps follow your advice and go with whoever gives them the biggest advance (and just forget about negotiating royalties since they are 'unlikely to earn back' in your words). However money is often not the major motivator as you mentioned.
I might have explained myself poorly, but I disagree here. I'm saying that if money (long term) is the motivator they should go for whoever offers the biggest royalty rate. As I showed, if PragProg published my book, I'd have earned the same with 2000 copies as I did at Apress with 8500 copies (or thereabouts) :)
Sure they'll give up royalties but they will receive what they want. Small and medium-sized publishers will generally not have the resources and expertise to perform those same functions at the scale a big publishing house can do them.
Not always. I think the Pragmatic Programmers do an incredible PR job - especially as they have a PR umbilical cord with O'Reilly. Apress, on the other hand, shut down their entire Berkeley marketing department recently (and lost some great people).
Your case of selling 8500 copies through Apress vs. 2000 through Pragmatic Programmer is important since some might perceive that the book was a failure because it "only" sold 2,000 copies. And those "some people" might include potential employers, industry colleagues or the author.
But.. most authors don't publicly disclose their sales. There are quite a few other Ruby books published at Apress and I'd be interested to know how they've sold.. ;-) There are ways to get rough figures but they're as accurate as using Compete for Web stats (IME).
It also does not take into account the perceived prestige someone might feel with being accepted to be an Apress author vs. a PP author (again "some people" might have never heard of PP books and so it might not have the same weight).
In my limited experience, and especially amongst the Ruby world, I'd argue being a PP author has more prestige than being an Apress author - perhaps only trumped by being an O'Reilly author.. I know this isn't your point though ;-)
Apress starts to take notice and they hire someone to write the Beginning Ruby book for them and they market the shit out of it. What do you do now? You l-o-s-e, that's what. PP can't afford to market your book - they don't have any budget left after your 50% royalty and paying their staff - so you are SOL.
You make some good points in this paragraph but I don't think they apply for me or my market - though they might in other situations. There are other introductory Ruby books from more popular publishers out there but mine still outsells them - and this isn't because Apress is doing a great marketing job.
- ScottWhigham 17y agoThanks for taking the time to give such a detailed response. "I'm saying that if money (long term) is the motivator they should go for whoever offers the biggest royalty rate." If you re-read what I wrote, I was specifically talking about the "very niche book" that would not likely earn back the advance (hence the royalty rate is not something to worry about). For other situations (i.e. the book you expect will be very popular) then of course I agree with you. If money is the primary motivator and you still want to write books then do what you said: get ready to write several books. All together, a fun diversion for my day. Thanks, Peter!
- petercooper 17y agoIf you re-read what I wrote, I was specifically talking about the "very niche book" that would not likely earn back the advance (hence the royalty rate is not something to worry about). Good point. Sorry, I missed that reference. In that case yes, I agree on the math, though gleefully accepting a (relatively) big advance for a book you believe won't sell too well could burn some bridges ;-)
- ScottWhigham 17y agoPossibly - however there is a difference between "gleefully accepting" a big advance and "squeezing every last dime out of the bastard publishing company"!
- chromatic 17y ago> I think the Pragmatic Programmers do an incredible PR job - especially as they have a PR umbilical cord with O'Reilly. Really? I've been very dissatisfied with the latter's PR. It seems like a combination of asking authors to write more for free, tweeting once a month "Hey, here's a link to a book catalog page!", and sending free copies to people hoping they'll write reviews. It hasn't been worth the amount of money they take from gross sales.
- ScottWhigham 17y agoThanks for chiming in. Since we are somewhat comparing and contrasting big publisher vs. small/mid publisher, do you think that a bigger company (like O'Reilly for example) would have done it differently? If so, how? I've not published through O-Reilly so I can't really speculate.