3 ms·
I am sorry, but the authors' examples and parallels doesn't make much sense to me. First of all, what does sample rate has even remotely to do with hearing ran
by dzhiurgis 12y ago
I am sorry, but the authors' examples and parallels doesn't make much sense to me.
First of all, what does sample rate has even remotely to do with hearing range?
If we are comparing this to visual information, perhaps it would be best to draw parallels with video. Namely, sample rate would be equal to frames per second and bit depth to colour depth. In both areas we are still seeing improvements from TV manufacturers (100Hz TVs) and gamers are still racing to get better fps so it looks more realistic.
The question then would be, why 25 fps is the minimum average human can withstand? What are the limits here and can it look more realistic for certain people with more frames per second.
After all, this race for fidelity is just attempt to get more accurate representation of analog sound, which opens different problem - absolute all of todays music is electronic - produced from samples and samples above 44KHz are simply not available. You may find some vinyl rips of more classical music (which does explain the phenomenon why so many rock stars would start listening to classic music - after getting rich and dumping money into expensive sound systems they'd discover elegance beyond distortion).
Saying all this fidelity does not matter is kind of equivalent of throwing away all the vinyls (although transistors play a role here too).
- smosher_ 12y ago> If we are comparing this to visual information, perhaps it would be best to draw parallels with video. But it isn't. We perceive pitch more like we perceive color than how we perceive motion. "Motion" in audio is well below the frequency of pitch. Same goes for video really, but in video the framerate has nothing to do with the color, unlike how the sampling rate has to do with sound frequency in (cough most) digital formats. If color in video was sampled the way pitch is in audio, we would have framerates in the high terahertz range.
- smosher_ 12y agoCan't edit: on topic, accurate response -> downvotes. Stay classy HN.
- wander_homer 12y ago"First of all, what does sample rate has even remotely to do with hearing range?" The sample rate (among a few other things like the quality of the low-pass filter) determines what's the highest frequency you can perfectly read from a signal. Since most human beings can't hear frequencies above 20 kHz you simply need to choose a sample rate that can represent a 20 kHz signal perfectly and that's something like 44 or 48 kHz.
- dzhiurgis 12y agoOk that does make sense and indeed defines overall distortion. Moreover, what his video shows is example with single tone, while reality is that single instrument would produce multitude tones and typical track would employ multiple instruments.