7 ms·
No one can see X-rays (or infrared, or ultraviolet, or microwaves). It doesn't matter how much a person believes he can. Retinas simply don't have the sensory h
by nkurz 12y ago
No one can see X-rays (or infrared, or ultraviolet, or microwaves). It doesn't matter how much a person believes he can. Retinas simply don't have the sensory hardware.
The author seems to have stumbled into a poor example, as a recent study shows that humans can indeed see infrared light using an unexpected process. Should we read anything into the audio case from this? Probably not, but it's a sign that even those who are sure they are right because they have science on their side should retain some degree of openmindedness.
Human infrared vision is triggered by two-photon chromophore isomerization
This study resolves a long-standing question about the
ability of humans to perceive near infrared radiation (IR)
and identifies a mechanism driving human IR vision. A few
previous reports and our expanded psychophysical studies
here reveal that humans can detect IR at wavelengths longer
than 1,000 nm and perceive it as visible light, a finding
that has not received a satisfactory physical explanation.
We show that IR light activates photoreceptors through a
nonlinear optical process. IR light also caused
photoisomerization of purified pigments and a model
chromophore compound. These observations are consistent
with our quantum mechanical model for the energetics of
two-photon activation of rhodopsin. Thus, humans can
perceive IR light via two-photon isomerization of visual
pigment chromophores.
http://www.pnas.org/content/early/2014/11/25/1410162111 http://www.pnas.org/content/early/2014/11/25/1410162111
- aroman 12y agoTalk about recent... that article was published yesterday.
- alecdbrooks 12y agoIn case some people skipped the bottom: >Edits and corrections made after this date are marked inline, except for spelling errors spotted on Dec 30, 2012 and March 15, 2014, and an extra 'is' removed on April 1, 2013 That study is 8 months and 16 days younger than the last edit to the article.
- sillysaurus3 12y agoOpenmindedness isn't the same thing as being open to accepting a mistaken belief. If no one can tell the difference between 24-bit and 16-bit, then 24-bit simply doesn't matter. The only way to know is with a controlled experiment that checks whether the people can detect no better than chance whether music is 24-bit.
- nkurz 12y agoOpenmindedness isn't the same thing as being open to accepting a mistaken belief. Perhaps not, but I think it's very close. I'm not advocating for noncritical acceptance of anything, but making the point that any jump from "X is a physical law" to "Y is impossible" depends critically on the assumption that the only way to achieve Y is through X, and that there is no possibility of a back door that entirely sidesteps X. This not be openmindedness exactly, but failing to account for this possibility strikes me as an example of closedmindedness. The only way to know is with a controlled experiment that checks whether the people can detect no better than chance whether music is 24-bit. Which people, which music, under what circumstances? And whose results do you trust? I feel safe guessing that many companies selling high-end audiophile quackery claim to have done tests showing that their equipment makes a positive difference to sound quality. Some of them are simply lying, some are misinterpreting their data, others have something real too small to be reliably measurable, and a tiny remainder might have a genuine breakthrough because they are approaching an unsolvable problem in a way that sidesteps the previous barriers. The question is how much openmindedness is right to account for this probability without being overwhelmed by the garbage. If no one can tell the difference between 24-bit and 16-bit, then 24-bit simply doesn't matter. I'd probably make the bet that there exist certain 24-bit sound files that certain listeners can discern from the same sound file that has been downsampled to 16-bit. While the difference may well be too small to be actually considered "better", I don't think that any physical laws that prevent this. I think it would be fun to see such a test. This Youtube video on "overtone singing" might offer insight on the sorts of effects that might be enhanced by the greater bit depth: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UHTF1-IhuC0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UHTF1-IhuC0
- aidenn0 12y ago
- ay 12y agoThe thread at https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8210878 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8210878 (assuming StavrosK was not lying like one of the comments suggested), shows an interesting discrepancy in the vision of different people.
- hansjorg 12y agoMonty actually mentions this in the footnotes of the article: > The original version of this article stated that IR LEDs operate from 300-325THz (about 920-980nm), wavelengths that are invisible. Quite a few readers wrote to say that they could in fact just barely see the LEDs in some (or all) of their remotes. Several were kind enough to let me know which remotes these were, and I was able to test several on a spectrometer. Lo and behold, these remotes were using higher-frequency LEDs operating from 350-380THz (800-850nm), just overlapping the extreme edge of the visible range.
- ay 12y agoThanks, I missed this addition! So there are even two moving targets - the LEDs' lower wavelength and different humans' higher wavelength.
- geographomics 12y agoMore rarely, there's also tetrachromacy, which is thought to improve colour differentiation within the visible spectrum, and aphakia, which causes an increased sensitivity to the near ultraviolet.
- chc 12y agoFrom what I can make of it, it doesn't sounds like that's really the same thing as seeing the infrared part of the spectrum, at least not the way people would normally mean it. It sounds like an effect that makes photons from infrared light simulate green light.
- X-Istence 12y agoIs this what allows me to see the very faint red/purplish glow of IR led's that form the ring around a lot of security camera's? Or the IR light that is used to photograph my license plate for the license plate tolls? Or is that just imperfections in the creation of the IR light in the first place?