3 ms·
Such "studio" formats don't make sense for end-user listening, but they make sense as inputs to further processing, mixing, etc. Having a pile of headroom in f
by JoshTriplett 12y ago
Such "studio" formats don't make sense for end-user listening, but they make sense as inputs to further processing, mixing, etc. Having a pile of headroom in frequency and amplitude means that after further processing you can subsequently output a sensible 16-bit 48kHz file without loss. If you start with a 16-bit 48kHz file and then do a pile of processing, you won't necessarily preserve the same degree of quality.
- scw 12y agoMost of the places selling these files don't include disclaimers about how the additional quality is only useful in studio conditions -- they use it as a differentiator in the marketplace for end listeners. The article does mention the need for higher quality in production environments: > Also, there are (and always will be) reasons to use more than 16 bits in recording and production. > None of that is relevant to playback; here 24 bit audio is as useless as 192kHz sampling. The good news is that at least 24 bit depth doesn't harm fidelity. It just doesn't help, and also wastes space.
- Carrok 12y agoHe mentions this specifically in the article several times. He agrees with you. The discussion is end-user listening.
- masklinn 12y agoThis he notes, repeatedly. The context of the post is 24/192 for distribution to end-users (Neil Young's PonoMusic)
- shmerl 12y agoThe article mentions this point.