3 ms·
A rather obvious premise is that there is some limit of immigration that is in the best interest of current US citizens. Average human brains are not a scarce
by PeterisP 12y ago
A rather obvious premise is that there is some limit of immigration that is in the best interest of current US citizens.
Average human brains are not a scarce resource as seen by all practical evidence - globally, they're being manufactured at near-record numbers, they're a sustainable resource that we can make more in the future, they're not fully used (9 million of them unemployed) and we're okay with deliberately throwing away many of them (e.g. incarcerating 2 million).
In addition, there is significant unequality between the regions of the world. Simply equalizing the global wealth per capita would be a very unwanted change for most of the first world, simply being pushed down to the average would be a catastrophic decrease. Equal opportunities for everyone worldwide would also hurt current first world citizens, who right now do have significantly above average opportunities. You can charge an order of magnitude more for the same job or service simply because you are here and "they" are not. It is rather obvious that there are some practical reasons why they would vote to preserve the status quo.
- dllthomas 12y agoArguably the incarcerated, and more tenuously then unemployed, are not "average human brains". I'm not sure I'd actually argue that but it seems worth addressing.
- AnthonyMouse 12y agoIncarceration is much more highly correlated to your parents income level than their genetics. Unemployment is primarily a skillset mismatch problem. Becoming a newspaper pressman looked like a solid career choice in 1995, not so much twenty years later when those 18 year olds are 38 and unemployed. Not foreseeing the rise of the internet is hardly strong evidence that their brains are defective.
- dllthomas 12y ago"Incarceration is much more highly correlated to your parents income level than their genetics." Nothing requires any stipulation that these minds be genetically inferior.
- AnthonyMouse 12y agoIf the problem is nurture rather than nature then shouldn't we be sending them to school rather than prison?
- dllthomas 12y agoPresented with an individual, it actually doesn't matter whether the problem was nature or nurture. What matters is what you can do about it now. Bear in mind that I brought this up as a possible objection that needed addressing, to the argument "we don't need more average minds - look at all the average minds we're not using".
- AnthonyMouse 12y ago> Presented with an individual, it actually doesn't matter whether the problem was nature or nurture. What matters is what you can do about it now. But that's the problem. Doing something with the late 30s unskilled laborer with no job is something we might be able to just break even on, or at least not lose too much in retraining for humanitarian reasons, and doing that is arguably better than abandoning those people to a life of crime and prison. But importing a significant number of new people who are already in that situation is not an economically positive proposition.
- dllthomas 12y agoLetting people take the jobs that best fit them, the world over, means more jobs are better done sooner, which means more resources available to do things like retrain. None of this has much to do, anymore, with the question of whether there is "demand for average human brains", incidentally.
- AnthonyMouse 12y ago> Letting people take the jobs that best fit them, the world over, means more jobs are better done sooner, which means more resources available to do things like retrain. But we're not talking about the world over. Allowing unlimited immigration is good for the immigrants but bad for the existing citizens. And you're running straight into equality fallacy. Equality is not an unambiguous good. When most people are poor, making everyone equal just makes everyone poor. There is a threshold past which people can stop worrying about where their next meal is coming from and instead make investments in the future of the world. The ideal eventual outcome is for everyone to be above that level, but if you flatten the world-wide income graph today then nobody is and the people who are are the only ones who can drag everyone else up. In the meantime the distinction between who gets to be a citizen of a first world country and who doesn't is inherently arbitrary and unfair, but it's still a choice that has to be made.
- IndianAstronaut 12y agoWhile there is an income discrepancy, western countries and companies are hungry for developing markets. You can't have entry into those markets while putting up barriers of your own. Go to any street corner in India or Mexico and you will see US and other western brands everywhere.
- PeterisP 12y agoTrade protectionism is a completely different issue from immigration and I don't see how it's relevant here. That being said, you definitely can have entry into those markets while putting up barriers of your own, there are many historical examples when this was successfully done, e.g. 19th century was probably a peak of such practices. The only question is if you should, and if it's worthwhile right now - you can go to any place in USA and you'll see lots of things that are manufactured in Mexico. And the relationship is exactly the opposite of what is implied by your comment - a large wage disparity means that the developing markets aren't as "useful" as is their cheap labor; if wages would become more equal, then this change would generally reduce the outsourcing of labor to the third world and increase the export of goods made in USA to India or Mexico.
- IndianAstronaut 12y ago>Trade protectionism is a completely different issue from immigration and I don't see how it's relevant here. This has gone into both immigration and outsourcing, so it does become relevant. >there are many historical examples when this was successfully done This was to the detriment of those who were blocked from trade. The power balance between the west and the rest of the world isn't as skewed today so such would not be possible. >a large wage disparity means that the developing markets aren't as "useful" as is their cheap labor; This is a fundamental flaw in your logic and most in this thread. A person is both a worker and consumer. The same person that is working for money is going to consume with that money. When an immigrant arrives to the US, they become both worker and consumer. Their consumption drives the creation of more products, including software products.