5 ms·
Great post. I completely agree, and was making this same argument to someone yesterday. There are a few important trends and facts: - Containerization allows m
by chatmasta 12y ago
Great post. I completely agree, and was making this same argument to someone yesterday. There are a few important trends and facts:
- Containerization allows more tenants-per-server than virtualization
- The entire business model of cloud computing is maximizing tenants-per-server
- Because containerization has a direct cost benefit to cloud providers, they will adopt it quickly
- Quick adoption of containerization will trigger a "new wave" similar to when Linux gained mass adoption
- Cloud companies are scrambling to invest in hot containerization rather than build their own
- Docker has developer street cred and a solid team
- Post-dotcom, post-web2.0, companies invest in open source software now. This is new.
- Cloud companies compete with each other
- Different cloud companies invested in Docker, CoreOS
- Docker, CoreOS are competing
My logic is a bit fragmented, but all the necessary facts are there, and the conclusion that logically follows from them is that it makes rational business sense for CoreOS to diverge from Docker. There's billions of dollars at stake in the latest "platform war" (previous wars include desktop, server, mobile) -- the battle for the cloud. Containerization directly reduces costs and the "metric that matters" for cloud hosts, tenants-per-server. Therefore any open source company with a good containerization solution is going to attract a lot of investment. But bigcorp A does not want to rely on strategic direction of bigcorp B. Therefore they diverge their open source offerings.
It makes sense from a business perspective, and it's kind of sad from an open source perspective, but also good if you believe in free market economics. The question is, how much do free market economics apply in open source?
- dantiberian 12y agoContainerization directly reduces costs and the "metric that matters" for cloud hosts, tenants-per-server. the flip side of this coin is that it reduces the cost for every cloud provider. In essence containers moves the locus of competition further up the stack, commoditising the layers below. I'll bet there were a lot of people who were upset when shipping containers were standardised too.
- mrbill 12y agoI'll bet there were a lot of people who were upset when shipping containers were standardised too. There's a GREAT book on the subject: "The Box: How the Shipping Container Made the World Smaller and the World Economy Bigger" http://www.amazon.com/Box-Shipping-Container-Smaller-Economy/dp/0691136408 http://www.amazon.com/Box-Shipping-Container-Smaller-Economy...
- kiyoto 12y ago>The question is, how much do free market economics apply in open source? This is something I ask myself a lot (as someone focused 100% on open source at a company whose core business is not open source support). For all the hype that open source has enjoyed as a business model, it is much smaller/untested/too early to tell compared to the proprietary model. The most financially successful open source company to date is Red Hat, which, at 10B USD+, is a great success by anyone's measure. But that's the best any open source pure play company has done. If you look in the other direction, Oracle is worth 180B USD, and even a fledgling BI company like Tableau is in the high single digit billion. As much as I'd like open source companies to be an Oracle-grade blockbuster success, the brief story is not exactly promising.
- dantiberian 12y agoAs well as Red Hat has done, they are dwarfed by many other companies. This post about open source compressing the market size by 10x made a lot of sense, and was also a little depressing. http://kellblog.com/2014/11/18/it-aint-easy-making-money-in-open-source-thoughts-on-the-hortonworks-s-1/ http://kellblog.com/2014/11/18/it-aint-easy-making-money-in-...
- ojilles 12y agoBut isn't that exactly how innovation and disruption works? Taking a market and saying "we'll do it for 10x less".
- wmf 12y agoIt depends what kind of innovation. Disruption often involves business or marketing innovation combined with technical non-innovation. Shrinking a market by 10x can be a good way to ensure that there won't be enough profit left to invest in R&D.
- skriticos2 12y agoI guess it's a question of what the company is selling. Google for example uses huge stacks of open source to run their business. And even though they are far from being pure open source, they do contribute back to the community in multiple ways, for example with contributions to the Linux kernel and open source projects like Chromium and Go. And then there are projects like Qt, that mix open source tools with enterprise support. But I think that the field of IT is still extremely young and that in the future larger companies will discover that collaborating on open source platform and infrastructure projects will give them much better synergy effects and lower IT costs by removing the license cost and at the same time lowering the support cost. Compared to history, the 20-30 years that mainstream computing has is really just a spark and there is so much change coming that will be directed by market and competition.
- beachstartup 12y ago> - The entire business model of cloud computing is maximizing tenants-per-server this is not exactly true. the business model is to maximize the revenue per server, not the number of tenants. this can be done in a number of ways.
- chatmasta 12y agoGood point. Of course, one of those ways is by charging the same price-per-tenant but increasing the number of tenants-per-server. If multiple companies do this, we should expect the price-per-tenant floor to decrease.
- Someone1234 12y agoI liken containers to adding an extra row of seats on a commercial aircraft. Right now the airline (host) operates one aircraft (server) and can fit X number of seats on it (split due to both consumption but also overhead from the seat's depth (hypervisor overhead)). If containers have lower overhead than hypervisors then it would be akin to an airline buying thinner seats and getting an extra row in. However it does remain to be seen how much more efficient containers are over hypervisors, and also how secure they are (there are lot's of unanswered questions on the security front).
- derefr 12y agoI don't think most people are comparing containers to hypervisors (VMs); they're comparing using just VMs to using containers on top of VMs. Especially, they're comparing running one-VM-from-some-IaaS per workload, to running several of those workloads (possibly from multiple tenants) on top of the same VM-from-some-IaaS. If it wasn't insane to run a hypervisor within a hypervisor, this platform war would have started years ago, with Heroku taking AWS VMs and splitting them into tiny Heroku VMs.
- simonpantzare 12y agoMy understanding of Amazon's new container service is that it lets users spawn a bunch of instances that the service manages (job scheduling and so on). This is not maximizing tenants per server nor maximizing revenue per server, IMO, as it mainly lets users increase the workload per instance. Without the container service, unless they run the similar infrastructure themselves, users would have to run additional instances to have the same isolation and ease of deployment (if they use Puppet, Chef, Ansible, or whatnot instead of some Docker cluster management software).