4 ms·
I still don't see it being much better in practice. It's pretty rare to use ordinals to refer to intervals greater than 2 octaves. There is really virtually no
by baddox 12y ago
I still don't see it being much better in practice. It's pretty rare to use ordinals to refer to intervals greater than 2 octaves. There is really virtually no cognitive load required to hear "major tenth" and realize that it's a major 3rd plus an octave.
- thedufer 12y agoThere's virtually no cognitive load if you already know music theory. That's a very important distinction - music theory in its current state is completely undiscoverable for no good reason. How undiscoverable? I grew up in a fairly music-oriented family and played a lot of instruments as a kid, but didn't formally study music theory. It wasn't until I read parent that I realized "fifth", "third", etc. are 1-indexed ordinals, and not some inscrutable scheme involving fractions. Everything suddenly makes way more sense. I feel fairly confident that sane terminology would greatly ease this problem.
- baddox 12y ago> That's a very important distinction - music theory in its current state is completely undiscoverable for no good reason. I don't doubt that it could be improved, but I don't think it's all that bad, considering how many people do learn music theory.
- Leszek 12y ago> There is really virtually no cognitive load required to hear "major tenth" and realize that it's a major 3rd plus an octave. Maybe not for you, but it certainly took me a moment to convince myself that that is true.
- hamiltonkibbe 12y agoJust use modulo-seven arithmetic...
- Leszek 12y agoEr, yes, I believe that's the point the grandparent was making (and the parent was disagreeing with)
- hamiltonkibbe 12y agoI was just trying to show that changing the indexing from zero- to one-based makes no difference in this case. The same-octave interval will always be the multi-octave interval mod 7, regardless of whether you call the tonic 0 or 1.
- Leszek 12y agoGranted, but I was replying to a post stating that "it" is not better in practice, where "it" is using 0 base, mod 7 arithmetic. Anyway, yes, you've shown correctly that mod 7 arithmetic is useful, proving half the great-great-somethingth-parent's point. Now, the remaining interesting cases are the inversion case and the multiplication case, where 0 based is simpler (for me) than 1 based. Also, the idea of using the word "octave" for "mod 7" is already pretty broken, and is what caused me my initial hesitation.
- codyb 12y agoPretty irrelevant but that reminded me of this scene from Cannibal the Musical [0]. The whole video is worth watching, especially if you've seen the rest of the movie but I only linked to the music theory argument. The movie is one of Trey Parker's earlier works and is quite entertaining [1]. Coming from a family of musicians and artists, it's all pretty foreign to me. And I used to take lessons, and occasionally sit and work my way through a beginner guitar book. I've always heard music theory to be pretty obtuse and challenging. I'm sure if I put in some hours to understand the fundamentals it'd make a lot more sense, and read it at home with a little dedication it'd be a bit easier. It's truly interesting. [0] - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pF8oIKLlBsI#t=132 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pF8oIKLlBsI#t=132 [1] - http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0115819/?ref_=fn_al_tt_1 http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0115819/?ref_=fn_al_tt_1
- hamiltonkibbe 12y agoThere is some cognitive load, but it is certainly no more than it would be to hear "Major 9th" and realize that it's a Major 2nd plus an octave, as it would be in the zero-indexed case.