5 ms·
Why does every post on this subject always have someone come in to slam home the notion that the government is always inept in everything they do? Its really g
by colordrops 12y ago
Why does every post on this subject always have someone come in to slam home the notion that the government is always inept in everything they do? Its really good propaganda for keeping the public pacified. But it doesn't reflect reality. The government as well as its component organizations are not monolithic, and are made up of both bafoons and geniuses. Based on conversations I've had with people that have been part of the apparatus, the CIA is known to be somewhat incompetent when it comes to computer tech, but the NSA is phenomenal.
Stop apologizing for the government, whether conscious or not.
- username223 12y ago> Why does every post on this subject always have someone come in to slam home the notion that the government is always inept in everything they do? Because it's being read by programmers, a significant portion of whom are "libertarians." Just ignore them.
- dmix 12y agoHN used to have a libertarian lean to it back when it was a smaller community of programmers who were starting companies like Dropbox and AirBnB, people discussing SICP/Lisp, and willing to fill the homepage with Erlang articles to scare aware newbs. Now that it has been fully transitioned into mainstream site and much more like reddit, it is much less libertarian and more /r/politics. So that generalization doesn't apply so cleanly here anymore.
- username223 12y ago> starting companies like Dropbox and AirBnB, people discussing SICP/Lisp, and willing to fill the homepage with Erlang articles to scare aware newbs. That seems like "greed-heads, nerds, and old-school Usenet trolls."
- lorddoig 12y agoBecause they keep proving it over and over again? (at least in certain problem domains they do.) Government activities are generally important to a lot of people, if not because said people are direct consumers of the alleged benefits then because they paid for them. We keep paying and they keep ballsing it up, and everything we know about the theory of government (in an economic sense) tells us this is a design flaw and, ergo, not something that can be expected to self-resolve. And it's not that they're totally inept all the time (although ineptitude is a recurring theme) - sometimes they do get good stuff done. The much harder question to answer in these cases is how efficient was it? How much tax money was shat away in admin/stupid compliance BS, and is all that wasteful pomp really a necessary price to pay for democracy? Could there be another way? It's all very contentious, high-stakes stuff and if you disagree strongly enough with it all to wilfully not comply you'll soon find the whole system is propped up on various threats: they'll take your money, your home, your pride - they may even take you. And they'll do it all under a banner of moral righteousness that turns it into you vs. "society". How could that ever not be a talking point? I talk about it most days in one way or another, and not because I'm some horrible right-wing fanatic who wants to wipe my ass with money and glee in the suffering of others, but because it's an incredibly fragile, wasteful system that perpetually sits on a knife edge and I suspect does just as much harm as good. It's misguided in so many ways and so, so hard to change that all I can do is moan about it and hope that my moans contribute in some way to getting the volume of the debate loud enough to think that something could change. So, yeah, that's why I think it keeps coming up.
- superuser2 12y ago>Because they keep proving it over and over again? The incredibly complex and expensive purchasing/hiring system that seems to fail every single time exists because we don't trust government employees to spend our money. Perhaps we shouldn't. But you cannot deny that the system designed to prevent improper spending is the cause of a hell of a lot of improper spending. Government agencies are often legally bound to purchase from the lowest bidder even when they know the product will be "technically correct" but extremely low-quality. Because the regulations and processes are so complex, it is incredibly expensive and difficult to sell to the government, meaning the few companies that actually manage to do it have higher costs and less competition. Of course prices are high. Sure, the system is necessary to stop incompetent/malicious actors from wasting money or throwing contracts to their cronies. But it also stops a lot of smart and diligent people from getting the resources they need to complete their projects. If you want government agencies to be able to purchase high-quality goods and services at reasonable prices, then you're going to need to loosen the chains. And that probably means some fraud. And that probably means some agencies buying slightly nicer stuff than the absolute cheapest thing that would work on paper. But the overall effectiveness of government might end up higher, and its cost much lower, if you were to eliminate the "government services" industry and open it to the wider market.