4 ms·
Parenthood, the Great Moral Gamble
- perlgeek 12y agoOn the one hand, those are very interesting questions to discuss. On the other hand, getting/having children is a deeply rooted desire/need in humans, and passing judgement on it feels like passing judgement on the decision to eat food, sleep, breath, or having sex. Can you blame somebody for eating when hungry? Even when it has far-reaching consequence some fifteen years later?
- rayiner 12y agoMany people talk about kids who grow up to be serial killers, or bringing another child into an overcrowded world, but ignore the aggregate value of the tremendous joy people experience simply being alive. I think often, we in the first world cannot fathom how poor people can be happy. But the fact is that something as simple as sharing a meal with family is a source of joy for people the world over, and the magnitude of that joy is not proportional to whether you live in the West Village or in an actual village. This is a bit metaphysical, but in my opinion there is a cosmic opportunity cost to not having kids--a lost opportunity for a human person to experience the joy of being alive.
- rwcarlsen 12y agoAmen.
- dminor 12y ago> This is a bit metaphysical, but in my opinion there is a cosmic opportunity cost to not having kids--a lost opportunity for a human person to experience the joy of being alive. By this logic you should have as many children as possible.
- rayiner 12y agoBy that logic, all else being equal, society in the aggregate (not necessarily any individual) should have as many kids as possible. I don't think it's such a far fetched idea. I think at least one of the subconscious appeals of Star Trek is that it's a story where humanity is freed from being tied to a single world, and populates worlds all over the galaxy.
- ctdonath 12y agoMost religions regard numerous children as a blessing.
- qznc 12y agoThis article reads like a confused run in circles [0]. Parents are responsible for kids they cannot control? How can you be responsible for something you have no control over?? Sure, there is a tendency to blame parents of evildoers, but that is fallacy of the accuser, not the parents. [0] @native speaker: Is there a good phrase for this?
- AnimalMuppet 12y ago"A confused run in circles" is perhaps a bit awkward, but it communicates well enough. Perhaps more idiomatic would be to say "This article seems to chase itself in circles" or "... seems to wander in circles". But in my opinion, neither is a large improvement over your original phrasing.
- coldtea 12y ago>How can you be responsible for something you have no control over? In the general case, this is very easy and logical: by unleashing it to the world. Isn't that the idea behind the "Sorcerer's Apprentice" (famous from Mickey Mouse's version in Fantasia)? http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Sorcerer%27s_Apprentice http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Sorcerer%27s_Apprentice
- ctdonath 12y ago_Everything_ we do has a chance of causing harm. People regularly agonize over the potential of harm, often despite minuscule odds thereof. To become a sane productive adult, one must come to accept that harm may happen as consequence to an action, but not doing that action causes harm as well. Go forth with good intent in good faith; stark horrors may occur, but not doing so accumulates greater horror. http://4.bp.blogspot.com/-KKLOmJySIgk/TghkJ21To5I/AAAAAAAAA0c/qh1g73xU22s/s1600/bloom+county+much+too+eco-friendly.jpg http://4.bp.blogspot.com/-KKLOmJySIgk/TghkJ21To5I/AAAAAAAAA0...