5 ms·
Math Anxiety: Why Hollywood Makes Robots of Alan Turing and Other Geniuses
- swordswinger12 12y agoI don't care that I'm beating a dead horse here - if you haven't read Andrew Hodges' excellent biography of Alan Turing, you should put it on your holiday reading list. Link: http://www.amazon.com/Alan-Turing-Enigma-Inspired-Imitation/dp/069116472X/ref=tmm_pap_title_0?ie=UTF8&qid=1417457678&sr=8-1 http://www.amazon.com/Alan-Turing-Enigma-Inspired-Imitation/...
- CapitalistCartr 12y agoHollywood is mostly a system of aggregating tropes into stories. The minority sidekick, token minorities, the plucky Southern Women (Steel Magnolias? Really?), the imminint danger down to the second, etc. There is a book on movie plot writing called, "Save The Cat" that is the most insightful book I've read on that subject. The plot of "Avatar" was depressingly cliche; a standard retelling of the standard action movie plot, done once again. The special effects made it worth seeing, twice for me. Rarely does a movie rise above such things. http://www.amazon.com/Save-Last-Book-Screenwriting-Youll/dp/1932907009 http://www.amazon.com/Save-Last-Book-Screenwriting-Youll/dp/...
- mikeyouse 12y ago> The plot of "Avatar" was depressingly cliche; a standard retelling of the standard action movie plot, done once again. I liked when Avatar was described as "Pocahontas in Space". It's pretty interesting tooling around on TVTropes.org and seeing exactly how you can break down a movie into well-known and well-worn cliches. It reminds me a bit of high school literature critique. It used to bother me quite a bit when we'd tease out these meanings from books since I couldn't believe that authors spent their time trying to come up with hidden metaphors on every page. It took a long time to change my perspective to recognize that these books were successful decades after they've been written because of those buried metaphors and tropes. All of the books that were facile and poorly written disappear into history, and whether the authors intended every single sunset to mean something unique, the books are worth studying because they connect in that way and for whatever reason, we connect with those meanings. Warning for those who get sidetracked easily, TVTropes is a worse wormhole than wikipedia, but it's endlessly interesting to see what's behind successful media: http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Film/Avatar http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Film/Avatar
- pzxc 12y agoYeah, the plots of Avatar and Pocahontas are so identical that you can literally take a synopsis and play Mad Libs substituting the character names and it describes both perfectly. The ultimate laziness of avatar: The mineral they're after that is so hard to find that is the basis for the movie, what shall we call it? Ahem, unobtainium yeah that's a good name! I laughed out loud in the movie theater when they revealed that.
- fdej 12y agoI disagree that the name unobtanium is an example of lazy writing. I always took it for an in-universe joke (doubling as a meta-joke), and/or a deliberately gimmicky marketing name invented by the corporation. There are plenty of playful scientific terms in the real world (the "sonic hedgehog" protein just to take one example).
- anigbrowl 12y agoThe whole point of 'unobtanium' is to draw attention to the allegorical nature of the film.
- gizmo686 12y ago>The ultimate laziness of avatar: The mineral they're after that is so hard to find that is the basis for the movie, what shall we call it? Ahem, unobtainium yeah that's a good name! Maybe they are mispronouncing Ununpentium.
- Chinjut 12y agoIs that really lazy? It's exactly the sort of name I can imagine cheeky scientists coming up with, perhaps starting off jokey but eventually losing all such connotation and simply becoming standard. Are names such as "strange quarks", "Big Bang", "oobleck" (taken from Dr. Seuss), etc., so dry and dignified?
- kian 12y agoMy physics teacher used to say: "Take a massless, frictionless, inextensible rope made of pure unobtanium..."
- technofiend 12y agoThe structure of most stories fall into one of a few categories; in fact Kurt Vonnegut's rejected Master's Thesis was based on cataloging those categories and diagramming their structures. http://www.openculture.com/2014/02/kurt-vonnegut-masters-thesis-rejected-by-u-chicago.html http://www.openculture.com/2014/02/kurt-vonnegut-masters-the... Really what makes it interesting is in the telling of the story. Did you end up writing Star Wars: A New Hope or another I Love Lucy episode?
- luckydata 12y agoThe work of Vladimir Propp was better, and more applicable to a wider variety of stories. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vladimir_Propp http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vladimir_Propp
- hga 12y agoThen again, that first Star Wars movie is mostly taken from Kurosawa's The Hidden Fortress (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Hidden_Fortress https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Hidden_Fortress), right down to the personalities of the robots... I gather The Dam Busters and perhaps other films of that sort (none of which I've seen) get a lot of credit for the end.
- olavk 12y ago"Mostly taken from..." is really stretching it. Yeah he was inspired by those movies, but to say "mostly taken from" is ignoring all the things which is original about the movie. And Star Wars really was an original movie when it arrived. If you look at Shakespeare almost all his basic story lines (and many characters) are taken from history or from other plays or stories. That does not mean that Shakespeares plays are "mostly taken from" earlier sources.
- whistlerbrk 12y agoThe movie was lazy. They employed the same old brilliant "a ha" moment of insight at the bar they have done in so many others. Run to the office! Eureka! Bollocks. They can't seem to imagine a world where its hard work that actually pays off.
- olavk 12y agoMaybe they can imagine - writing movies is also hard work, believe it or not. But they also know that sitting at a desk and calculating for years is not very entertaining to look at.
- Animats 12y agoMr. Turing was a British math prodigy who during World War II broke a supposedly unbreakable Nazi code. He made a programmable machine, which took the information from one task to execute the next, reaching powerful conclusions. So much wrong there. Polish cryptographers broke Enigma, and built the first "bombe", a key-testing machine. Turing figured out how to speed up the process, at a cost in wiring complexity. Turing never "built a programmable machine", although he conceptualized one. Flowers designed Colossus, which wasn't a general purpose computer, just an electronic key-tester, like a Bitcoin mining ASIC. At Bletchly Park, Turing was part of a team headed by Dilly Knox, working with John Jeffreys and Peter Twinn. There's a forgotten history of electronic digital non-general-purpose computing devices: Teleregister (stock quotes), International Totalizator (racetracks), and Reservisor (airline reservations). The WWII cryptanalysis machines, and the ENIAC, all belong to that category. Programming of those involved big plugboards, not loading memory with a program. That sort of thing disappeared in the 1970s, as CPUs became cheaper. (It's back, with FPGAs and ASICs used for high-performance special purpose tasks like packet routing.) The real inventor of the modern computer was John von Neumann, who's never had a movie about him. He's the one who insisted that random access memory, with both code and data in the same memory, was the way to go, and that computers should work in binary. His 1946 paper (http://www.cs.princeton.edu/courses/archive/fall12/cos375/Burks.pdf http://www.cs.princeton.edu/courses/archive/fall12/cos375/Bu...) describes most of basic computer architecture, and will look very familiar to anyone who knows how a simple CPU works. In his spare time, he did some design work on the implosion system for the first atomic bomb, and, using an early computer he designed, the EDSAC, some of the design work for the H-bomb. Also lots of good papers on math and quantum mechanics. Von Neumann was a party guy, known for his dinner parties at the Institute for Advanced Study at Princeton. Married twice, divorced once. Not much angst in his life; he was a cheerful sort and had a good life. Died young, in 1957 at age 53, so he didn't get to see the computer era really take off. Even less well known is the inventor of modern cryptanalysis, William F. Friedman. Friedman turned cryptanalysis from a guessing game to a number-crunching problem. He headed the effort that broke the Japanese "Purple" code, a tougher job than Enigma. Much of the theory behind cryptanalysis is his work. The auditorium at NSA headquarters is named after him. He was a military officer in WWI, married once. Famous quote: "No new cypher is worth looking at unless it comes from someone who has broken a very hard one." Friedman really did break some major cyphers on his own. Neither von Neumann nor Friedman had unusual personal lives, so they don't have movies. Both were probably smarter than Turing.