4 ms·

24 Pull Requests

89 points by andrewnez 12y ago

adambutler 12y ago
+1
andrewnez 12y ago
24 Pull Requests is back again for a 3rd year, encouraging people to give back to open source projects that they've been benefiting from all year. The site itself is also open source: https://github.com/24pullrequests/24pullrequests https://github.com/24pullrequests/24pullrequests
orng 12y ago
This is a great initiative and one that I would to be able to be a part of but I have such a hard time coming up with things to do. I have only made a few contributions to open source projects previously and all those were cases where I was using some open source library with limitations or flaws that I had to fix in order to be able to use them in my software and where I fixed them first for me and then decided to share them back with the world. In many cases I added or modified functionality through multiple checkins that amounted to rather large pull requests. I just have a hard time seeing how I will be able to a) find anything worthwhile to contribute and b) be able to do so every day.
- groks 12y ago
  Here are 179 basic Linux utilities... rpm -ql binutils coreutils moreutils moreutils-parallel \ findutils diffutils sharutils psutils \ pciutils iputils elfutils | grep -E /usr/s?bin ...some of which likely have parsing bugs which can be automatically identified with this fuzzer discussed on HN recently: http://lcamtuf.coredump.cx/afl/ http://lcamtuf.coredump.cx/afl/ Also, an exciting opportunity to discover what the 'pee' and 'sponge' commands do.
josteink 12y ago
You may wish to learn some new skills but wonder where to start. Or you may be curious about how, or with what, you can contribute to open-source software, in general or for projects you specifically rely on. Having your first patch accepted is a strange experience. It's hard to describe, but feels really, really good. Definitely recommended! For those who can allocate the time for it, this is a great initiative. It makes discovering potential projects where contributions are welcome easy, and it makes it easy to identify which projects which may be a good fit for your contributions. I have a relatively new project up and running, and I already see a couple of forks. I'm curious about what December will bring :)
escapologybb 12y ago
Just wanted to say that I'm not a programmer, but there are still things I can contribute to Open Source projects during this ace project. Fix those typos, add some documentation for a piece of software you use or myriad other things. I only mention it because I didn't realise this until somebody pointed it out to me! Also, for any JavaScript types out there looking for something to contribute to, this plugin[0] would help me fly a Quadcopter much easier! Just sayin' ;-) [0]:https://github.com/andrew/webflight-onscreen-keyboard https://github.com/andrew/webflight-onscreen-keyboard
- amirmc 12y ago
  Indeed, documentation and even quick tutorials are often overlooked but they're the first thing you look for when trying out a new project.
carreau 12y ago
Yeah, even more people dropping random patches, going away and not responding to questions. I would prefer people doing 1 pull request and taking care of it (test, docs) than getting 24 useless pull request. I had some pretty toxic behaviour last year because of this. Though I appreciate the idea I think it give a pretty bad idea to people of what Open Source are. I've just spend 4 hours on chat the last 2 days explaining a new comer how to use git/github and make a pull request; it was a pleasure. Though it is less and less the case when people just drop by and go away. I know I'm getting old and grumpy, but I feel the day I'll say the F word is getting closer. Please Someone open minus24pullrequest.com and ask people to help test and review code instead of just submitting extra work for maintainer.
- amirmc 12y ago
  Sounds like you've had some bad experiences here. Is your contribution process documented anywhere? IME well-meaning folks will generally try to conform to existing procedures if it's easy to find out what they are. The more time consuming PRs involve people new to Git/GitHub (and things like rebasing) but even then, I've only seen civil interactions.
Tombone5 12y ago
There seems to be barely more than one person per participating organization, wonder why.
praneshp 12y ago
Login using github doesn't seem to work (dns lookup failed), in case anyone from the site is reading comments.

89 points by andrewnez 12y ago

24 Pull Requests is back again for a 3rd year, encouraging people to give back to open source projects that they've been benefiting from all year. The site itself is also open source: https://github.com/24pullrequests/24pullrequests https://github.com/24pullrequests/24pullrequests

orng 12y ago

This is a great initiative and one that I would to be able to be a part of but I have such a hard time coming up with things to do. I have only made a few contributions to open source projects previously and all those were cases where I was using some open source library with limitations or flaws that I had to fix in order to be able to use them in my software and where I fixed them first for me and then decided to share them back with the world. In many cases I added or modified functionality through multiple checkins that amounted to rather large pull requests. I just have a hard time seeing how I will be able to a) find anything worthwhile to contribute and b) be able to do so every day.

groks 12y ago
Here are 179 basic Linux utilities... rpm -ql binutils coreutils moreutils moreutils-parallel \ findutils diffutils sharutils psutils \ pciutils iputils elfutils | grep -E /usr/s?bin ...some of which likely have parsing bugs which can be automatically identified with this fuzzer discussed on HN recently: http://lcamtuf.coredump.cx/afl/ http://lcamtuf.coredump.cx/afl/ Also, an exciting opportunity to discover what the 'pee' and 'sponge' commands do.

josteink 12y ago

You may wish to learn some new skills but wonder where to start. Or you may be curious about how, or with what, you can contribute to open-source software, in general or for projects you specifically rely on. Having your first patch accepted is a strange experience. It's hard to describe, but feels really, really good. Definitely recommended! For those who can allocate the time for it, this is a great initiative. It makes discovering potential projects where contributions are welcome easy, and it makes it easy to identify which projects which may be a good fit for your contributions. I have a relatively new project up and running, and I already see a couple of forks. I'm curious about what December will bring :)

escapologybb 12y ago

Just wanted to say that I'm not a programmer, but there are still things I can contribute to Open Source projects during this ace project. Fix those typos, add some documentation for a piece of software you use or myriad other things. I only mention it because I didn't realise this until somebody pointed it out to me! Also, for any JavaScript types out there looking for something to contribute to, this plugin[0] would help me fly a Quadcopter much easier! Just sayin' ;-) [0]:https://github.com/andrew/webflight-onscreen-keyboard https://github.com/andrew/webflight-onscreen-keyboard

amirmc 12y ago
Indeed, documentation and even quick tutorials are often overlooked but they're the first thing you look for when trying out a new project.

carreau 12y ago

Yeah, even more people dropping random patches, going away and not responding to questions. I would prefer people doing 1 pull request and taking care of it (test, docs) than getting 24 useless pull request. I had some pretty toxic behaviour last year because of this. Though I appreciate the idea I think it give a pretty bad idea to people of what Open Source are. I've just spend 4 hours on chat the last 2 days explaining a new comer how to use git/github and make a pull request; it was a pleasure. Though it is less and less the case when people just drop by and go away. I know I'm getting old and grumpy, but I feel the day I'll say the F word is getting closer. Please Someone open minus24pullrequest.com and ask people to help test and review code instead of just submitting extra work for maintainer.

amirmc 12y ago
Sounds like you've had some bad experiences here. Is your contribution process documented anywhere? IME well-meaning folks will generally try to conform to existing procedures if it's easy to find out what they are. The more time consuming PRs involve people new to Git/GitHub (and things like rebasing) but even then, I've only seen civil interactions.

Tombone5 12y ago

There seems to be barely more than one person per participating organization, wonder why.

praneshp 12y ago