4 ms·
Good concerns. One thing to add here is that often times in household HVAC system the thermostat relay doesn't handle the current for the heating/cooling eleme
by bravo22 12y ago
Good concerns.
One thing to add here is that often times in household HVAC system the thermostat relay doesn't handle the current for the heating/cooling element. Rather, it is the on/off relay for the main relay inside the heating/cooling device.
- analog31 12y agoYes, that's a good point. I'd still be cautious because a bug in your program could make your system run amok. And it could go either way with a home furnace: Shutting down during the winter could be as bad as running full-on, due to the danger of pipes freezing. At the very least, thinking through a failure mode analysis is a good mental exercise -- especially for folks who are accustomed to living in the world of pure software.
- foobarian 12y agoInteresting that you mention HVAC. I have had my furnace control board fail last month. The failure was in the power relay gating the power to the blower motor (which is a pretty hefty 1kW load). The relay had melted to a lump of charred plastic, and the circuit board around the relay pins turned into a hole. I guess no matter which way it failed there would've been no serious consequences (blower motor stuck on) so I classified the incident as "neat." :-)