7 ms·
Time perception, just like vision, is a construction of the brain
- SixSigma 12y ago> This may be why time seems to speed up as you age: you develop more compressed representations of events, and the memories to be read out are correspondingly impoverished. When you are a child, and everything is novel, the richness of the memory gives the impression of increased time passage—for example, when looking back at the end of a childhood summer. With no proof or otherwise, I had always conjectured that this was because time is compared proportionally. When I was 6, the three months of summer were approx 3 / 72 of my life = 1 / 24. When I am 60, those three months will occupy 1 / 240 of my life.
- josephagoss 12y agoThis is a little depressing isn't it? I wonder if there is any mechanism to counter this?
- rch 12y agoHow about living an atypically varied life with lots of travel and experimentation?
- ludamad 12y agoIn general I'm not sure, but certain substances give you the impression that time is going by very slowly.
- aoakenfo 12y agoI think the more thoughts you can process per minute, the more time begins to slow. Drugs could be a way to achieve this.
- westoncb 12y agoThat's not necessarily the case. Another possibility is that when it seems like time is passing more rapidly, it's because the events occurring have a lot of similarity to previously experienced events—so the brain compresses them. It fits the data in the same way: more things are novel when you're younger, less can be compressed. And, it fits exceptions to this rule that occur later in life (in my own experience anyway). To get around it, I think having less abstract experiences would be a good approach. If you're thinking in a highly abstract manner, maybe all your mornings might be identical and can be compressed into the unit 'morning.' In particular, I mean mindfulness, through meditation. Or you could just throw yourself into something new.
- digi_owl 12y agoHad similar thoughts about the brain and memories after getting in deep with de-duplication.
- abdias 12y agoI believe it's based on what the brain considers valuable information (or necessary to determine the situation). When you drive a longer distance the first time it seems like a year. After driving the same distance plenty of times the brain filters out the information as it's considered "safe" or of no value. The opposite happens if you are in an accident, the brain needs all the information it can get, time seem to slow down as a lot of information is taken in. Just my theory anyways; condensed: time perception is relative to information stream the brain takes in.
- Dwolb 12y agoAnother conjecture to consider is individual perception of time could be based on new experiences. That is, when experiences are mostly new, time feels slower. When most experiences are old (i.e. routine), time feels faster. This conjecture then tells one to go out and experience new things regularly!
- morokhovets 12y ago> This conjecture then tells one to go out and experience new things regularly! Or find a way to experience routines as fresh and new every time.
- mjklin 12y agoI think "time slowing" was the original inspiration for this subreddit (with no recent activity): http://www.reddit.com/r/SomethingNew/top/?sort=top&t=all http://www.reddit.com/r/SomethingNew/top/?sort=top&t=all
- madaxe_again 12y agoExcellent article. Thinking about it, 24fps (good old fashioned film), even though laughably low by the standards of modern displays, manages >1 frame per perceptual time-quanta, which is enough to give the illusion of motion. Any lower than that, and you start getting "frames" where there's no change in the film frame, and the motion illusion breaks down.
- apl 12y agoThat's not quite correct. a) 24FPS are easily detected as flickering; our true flicker fusion frequency is found around 60-80Hz. b) Perceptual time discretisation heavily depends on the modality and even the task in question. For motion extraction, this "limit" may be much lower or higher than for olfactory tasks or memory retrieval. Overall, it's really hard to put a time delta on neural processes -- after all, biological systems are more or less continuous.
- imaginenore 12y ago> 24FPS are easily detected as flickering; our true flicker fusion frequency is found around 60-80Hz. Shooter player here. This is a laughable statement. Pretty much anybody can tell the difference between 60hz and 120hz - even the mouse cursor moves smoother. Good players try to play at higher than 120hz rates, because it does make the difference.
- digi_owl 12y agoLikely because of how the various parts of a game engine interacts.
- imaginenore 12y agoNo. I'm telling you, get yourself a true 120hz or 144hz monitor, and you will see the difference for yourself.
- digi_owl 12y ago
- jfmercer 12y agoImmanuel Kant argued--some say proved--this very thing two centuries ago in his Critique of Pure Reason.
- jonsen 12y agoSo that is what consciousness is, the ability to construct a structured model of the world from disorganized unstructured signals. Well, consciousness is more than that. It is also self awareness. But to make a useful world model the brain has to constantly recalibrate model construction in reference to what you could call, well, what else but, the self.
- cristianpascu 12y agoIt's not possible to define something by it's ability to do something else. A smoker is not smoking cigarettes, nor inhaling smoke. Whatever is responsible for consciousness (and there's plenty evidence, more than to the contrary, that is not the brain), it can not be defined by what it does. Consciousness is not my reading the words I'm writing here, not me thinking the words before writing them in a foreign language. It's trivial to say that consciousness gives us the ability to do many things, still it escapes a definition mainly for the very fact that it does something, as opposed to everything else that falls under the umbrella of science(s), where description by attributes (e.g. the charge of the electron) sort of says what an objects says. It still escapes an ontological knowledge (we don't have the eye of God, as Putnam put it), but the electron doesn't really do anything, so we're not forced to explain something else than its properties, intrinsic or extrinsic.
- smtddr 12y agoYa know... at the end of the book "War and Piece", they really get into this stuff for quite a few pages. http://books.google.com/books?id=5ftPAQAAIAAJ&printsec=frontcover&source=gbs_ge_summary_r#v=onepage&q&f=false http://books.google.com/books?id=5ftPAQAAIAAJ&printsec=front... Page 330, Search for the sentence "What is the force that moves a people?" and read from there to be taken on some kinda existential journey.
- imaginenore 12y agoAny perception, by definition, is a construction of the brain.
- Houshalter 12y agoThe point of the article is the various ways time perception can be inaccurate.
- pwr22 12y agoWas going to post this, the title isn't great
- Strilanc 12y agoI wonder if the reason we find slow motion in movies interesting (e.g. makes things more salient) is related to the time-perception-slows-during-startles thing. (Assuming the startle slow-down is a side effect of the brain kicking up retention, based on the current experience having valuable information, we might learn to implicitly associate side-effects like time dilation with "this is valuable experience information". But mostly I have no idea what I'm talking about; I'm not even sure it's a well-formed testable idea.)
- pwr22 12y agoI think we find slo-mo interesting because it lets us experience the very passage of present time and events slowly, rather than just perceived passage which is after the fact.So we get to see things in a way we haven't before, which would presumably be more memorable and also would slow down perception of time passing....
- soylentcola 12y agoI think of it like zooming in on an image so that it's easier to process information in a higher resolution. Slow motion is like zooming in so that you can interpret things on a higher resolution as well (just on a different axis). Scrubbing back and forth across video is like interactive zoom where you can gather more precise information about a particular subset of the total data and compare to the whole.
- kordless 12y agoI've recently been playing Minecraft on 2b2t.org. The server has a regular lag which can be very annoying when you are starting out. In chat the other day, a player commented that he loved the lag saying it was 'part of the experience'. I started thinking about that and realized that the lag, if you assume it is always present, can be used as a tool. If you know lag is coming, you can do things that you know will be 'unwound' over the next X many seconds. That means you could fall into a hole and see what's in there, then when you lag warp back to where you were, decide not to go into the hole because there was nothing in it of interest. Imagine if we had that ability here.
- dschiptsov 12y agoAncient "mystics" knew this for ages. Using modern slang, it is an "environmental conditioning" and "habituation". Newly born babies presumably have no notion of time, except, perhaps, some bodily rithms, like states of sleep and being awake, but sleep too, has evolved the way it is partly due to day/night circle in our shared environment. Other creatures, notably deep water fish and mammals, have different mechanisms for "doing maintenance", like "switching between hemispheres", so they are never asleep (I am oversimplifying, of course). But it is clear that us and them have very different notion of time.
- icodestuff 12y agoHuh, I thought they did the falling/time dilation experiment on Mythbusters and found that the subjects could read the digits that were previously flashing too fast.
- rasz_pl 12y agogee wonder who got it right, bunch of entertainers on TV or scientist in a peer reviewed study?
- mytochar 12y agoYou mean the entertainers whose show, at the very basest level, is a show about doing (often) high-budget, high school science fair projects? In many of their more sciency, less blowy-up-y experiments, they're actually quite good about following the scientific method. If they had a large enough sample size, which when they bring in people for experiments is very easy to make large enough, then they are very likely measuring a real effect. The question is what are they measuring?
- naturalethic 12y agoNo shit
- harshbhasin 12y agoJohn Dobson (, the creator of the dobsonian telescope) in a very interesting interview on "Tonights show" says as follows: http://www.mystacki.com/#!/post/126/john-dobson:-on-the-tonight-show-part-1 http://www.mystacki.com/#!/post/126/john-dobson:-on-the-toni... We see a universe of matter and energy in space and time. Matter and energy are the same thing-- Einstein put that together with E=MC2; Space and time are the same thing. Einstein put those two together also with his theory of General Relativity and gravitation. Now whatever you look at you see it in the past (the light that carries the information has to reflect from an objects surface to your eye and that takes time.) You can't see anything when it happens. If you look at it from the point of view from Einstein's equations, the separation between you and what you see is always zero. You see things away from you in space by a trick of seeing backwards in time. You see the sun 8.5 light mins away by seeing it 8.5 light minutes ago. This what Indian philosophy calls Maya or illusion and maintains that space and time are mental concepts. Dobson terms Einstein's equations as the "Equations of Maya or Illusion" http://www.mystacki.com/#!/binder/41/john-dobson http://www.mystacki.com/#!/binder/41/john-dobson
- blago 12y agoI would love to see an Inception style movie script inspired by temporal integration.
- bambax 12y ago> At bottom, causality requires a temporal order judgment: did my motor act come before or after that sensory signal? The problem is, the brain is a causality-building machine; it loves to find causality where there is none. If you tell a room of 100 people the following story: "A person fell, there was a sound of a gunshot, and another person was seen running", and then ask each member of the audience to retell the story and explain what happened, a majority of the audience will reconstruct the story by placing the gun shot first, and explain that what happened is the person was killed by the gun. In this example, no perception-lag is involved; if a story doesn't make sense the way it's told, but makes sense with a few "minor" alterations, then the brain automatically makes those alterations in order to generate meaning. Hence: superstition, unreliability of witnesses, etc.
- Terr_ 12y agoThere's another layer of pattern-finding involved: "Why the hell is a person telling me these facts? If they're being told this way the other person must also believe they are related." It's like conditional probability: Knowing that they're being communicated to me, it's very likely these facts are related.
- pwr22 12y agoIndeed, we process relative to context which is usually what you want to do
- cap10morgan 12y agoDoes anyone know if there is an implementation of the key-press-light-flash-delay temporal illusion anywhere online? I'd love to try that out and experience the light flash "before" the key press after conditioning my brain to integrate the 200ms delay. If there isn't one, I may have to write it. It sounds really trippy.
- somberi 12y agoWe are meaning making machines. The longer we live, the more the "meaning-making" and hence it reflects as compressed time. However, meditation does "stretch" time back to how it felt like when I was a kid (in my memory at least).