2 ms·
If you remember correctly the last time I gave you a bunch of citations which you apparently did not take to heart. I remembered the earlier screen name better
by tokenadult 17y ago
If you remember correctly the last time I gave you a bunch of citations which you apparently did not take to heart.
I remembered the earlier screen name better than the more recent screen name that you are using here, but thanks for pointing out that you are the same person in both threads.
I'm still learning about this subject,
http://www.psych.umn.edu/courses/fall09/mcguem/psy8935/default.htm http://www.psych.umn.edu/courses/fall09/mcguem/psy8935/defau...
and I enjoy having what diplomats call a "frank exchange of views" with anyone else who enjoys reading about this subject. What I'm not seeing thus far is any experimentally verified proof that IQ/g/academic achievement/whatever is of interest is surely not malleable in the individual case. Rather, what I see repeatedly in the literature are surprising examples of environmental variables having much more power than they were expected to have, both across whole societies over time and in particular individual cases even with haphazard rather than planned environmental variation. But too often there is a leap from the statement that a trait is heritable to the incorrect and invalid conclusion that the trait is not malleable. I have seen that happen often in online discussion since 1992. What discordant identical twins, comparisons between neighboring countries, and other lines of evidence show is what the twin researchers say those lines of evidence show in their new 2009 paper: "even highly heritable traits can be strongly manipulated by the environment, so heritability has little if anything to do with controllability."
Johnson, Wendy; Turkheimer, Eric; Gottesman, Irving I.; Bouchard Jr., Thomas (2009). Beyond Heritability: Twin Studies in Behavioral Research. Current Directions in Psychological Science, 18, 4, 218.