3 ms·
“It ticked me off that somebody else is selling them when I was giving them away,” This is a really common. A person creates something and "licenses it freely"
by ChuckMcM 12y ago
“It ticked me off that somebody else is selling them when I was giving them away,”
This is a really common. A person creates something and "licenses it freely" out of their own generosity, and then someone goes and profits from it.
It illustrates a very deep conflict that has existed, presumably since artists existed, but really came to the fore in the age of silicon. The first example I saw sort of "first hand" was Ward Christensen's XMODEM, which he made public domain, was being sold to the US Government by a contractor who was using it in their product.
The legal question is pretty clear, you license it such that others can legally profit from it and there isn't an issue from the point of view of the law.
But what is the moral question? I've asked people in this situation (having their free stuff resold) and they split almost 50/50 on the moral one, which is half say "If they are making a profit they should share it with me." and half land in the "Good for them, but if they ask for support I'm going to charge quintuple my normal rate."
Clearly a lot of issues can be avoided by being courteous, but it really does provide something of a litmus test of people's true feelings with respect to open source.
- Swizec 12y agoThat's why creative commons share-alike exists. [1] Basically, you can use this freely as long as it's not for commercial purposes, and if you remix it in any way, then the result must be shared under the same license. It solves the dilemma pretty well I think. [1] http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/3.0/ http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/3.0/
- teddyh 12y agoYou don’t even need the “NC” (no commercial) clause to get this effect. There is no need to restrict commercial activity without cause.
- Flimm 12y agoWhat you said is true for by-nc-sa, but not for by-sa.
- twelvechairs 12y agoOften its an issue of magnitude though. If someone wants to use a photo I've taken very small in the corner of a 200 page document, which forms part of a piece of work they have been paid by the government to do, its probably not objectionable. If someone however sells my software slightly tweaked and rebranded, its probably not OK. There's a range of greys in there but the licencing is black and white.
- icebraining 12y agoGeneric licenses like these should be black and white, otherwise you'd get even more expectations mismatches. Thankfully, nothing forces you to use only a single license for your work! The best system for those grey cases, in my opinion, would be to publish the work under a NC license, but then add a message like "contact me if you want to use this work commercially" and offer specific licenses for such uses.
- teddyh 12y agoThis is exactly why the GPL (and other copyleft licenses like CC-SA) exists. I can’t find a reference, but I recall reading that Richard Stallman initially considered using a permissive license, but decided not to, because he did not want, and he assumed others also not to want, to be a “doormat”.
- Flimm 12y agoNo, this is not why the GPL was created. Richard Stallman has said repeatedly that he is fine with companies making money out of other people's GPLd software. The issue for him was whether derivatives were libre or not.
- schoen 12y agoThat's quite right, although the "doormat" sentiment is also true: https://www.gnu.org/events/rms-nyu-2001-transcript.html https://www.gnu.org/events/rms-nyu-2001-transcript.html "But the other issue I was thinking about was, I wanted to give the community a feeling that it was not a doormat, a feeling that it was not prey to any parasite who would wander along. If you don't use copyleft, you are essentially saying: [speaking meekly] “Take my code. Do what you want. I don't say no.” So, anybody can come along and say: [speaking very firmly] “Ah, I want to make a non-free version of this. I'll just take it.” And, then, of course, they probably make some improvements, those non-free versions might appeal to users, and replace the free versions. And then, what have you accomplished? You've only made a donation to some proprietary software project." RMS felt that what would make him a "doormat" was if his code ended up in a proprietary program, not if someone made money from it.