I would share this position. Montreal has a particularly bad case going on, where for a large part of the 90s it showed on the city employees payslips that the

I would share this position. Montreal has a particularly bad case going on, where for a large part of the 90s it showed on the city employees payslips that they were making pension contributions, but in reality the city just kept the money and said they'd pay it later (a "pension holiday"), but never did. The pensions in question do happen to be unreasonably large, but that was the problem that should have been dealt with at the time and not just kicked down the road. The city now want to get out of paying, which is a ludicrous position, in the same way that expecting new employees to get such generous pensions is insane.