4 ms·
Markdown. Is. Not. A. Language. Markdown was never intended to have any particular standardized syntax -- it was simply a script that took a common syntax used
by BerislavLopac 12y ago
Markdown. Is. Not. A. Language.
Markdown was never intended to have any particular standardized syntax -- it was simply a script that took a common syntax used for a long time when formatting plain text and convert it to formatted HTML. The attempts to standardize it are misguided, as there is absolutely no need for that -- there are numerous existing standards for precisely that, starting with ReST which follows a pretty similar syntax (in fact, any attempt to standardize Markdown will end up with something very similar, as it has to solve all the same issues).
- toolz 12y ago>Markdown was never intended to have any particular standardized syntax At some point it was intended to be standardized or else we wouldn't have a standardized version of markdown syntax.
- sitharus 12y agoBut there isn't a standardised version of Markdown. There's John Gruber's original syntax, and there are dozens if not hundreds of variants. When some enterprising people declared they had created "Standard Markdown" the original author got very upset: http://blog.codinghorror.com/standard-markdown-is-now-common-markdown/ http://blog.codinghorror.com/standard-markdown-is-now-common... Markdown does not have standards, it's just a collection of base formatting conventions a lot of people like.
- pyre 12y ago> There's John Gruber's original syntax, and there are dozens if not hundreds of variants. All of the variants exist due to the many undefined edge cases in the original syntax, and not further development by Gruber to 'officially' resolve ambiguities. Some of them became their own standards (e.g. MultiMarkdown) others just became undocumented behaviours of certain Markdown parsers and/or generators when handling edge-cases with no defined 'official' way to handle them. > When some enterprising people declared they had created "Standard Markdown" the original author got very upset: This seems to have more to do with the name being 'Standard Markdown' and seeing it as an attempt to usurp 'ownership' of the 'Markdown' name. Said author didn't flip out over variants like MultiMarkdown. > Markdown does not have standards, it's just a collection of base formatting conventions a lot of people like. The efforts of people to standardize it are efforts to resolve this idea, and make Markdown more formal.
- stormbrew 12y agoSince when does something have to have a standard syntax to be a language? I mean, if you said "it's not a programming language" because it's not really executable in even a limited sense, I'd get that, but to say it's not a language -- a means of communicating information -- is just absurd. There's no standard BASIC, and there are almost certainly hundreds if not thousands of variants of it, but no one would say it's not a language because of that.
- BerislavLopac 12y agoNo, I meant a "markup language". And you're right -- Markdown is not "a means of communicating information"; it's a script that converts one form of information to another.
- Retra 12y agoMarkdown isn't a means of communicating information?
- BerislavLopac 12y agoOnly partially. Technically, it is simply a conversion mechanism that converts one form of formatted text (the "Markdown" syntax) to another (HTML). Now, since the original format has never been formally specified, instead only being loosely defined by years of practice in email and Usenet messages, Gruber had to specify some constraints for his script to follow, but this is far from a standard. If we assume there is a standard, it's not called "Markdown", as Gruber heavily opposes that. On the other hand I'll agree that, if we extend the meaning of the term "Markdown" to cover a stantard like CommonMark, in that case yes, Markdown is a means of communicating relatively minor elements of information -- such as emphasis or lists -- as any other markup language.