4 ms·
It's basically the same reason people shouldn't sign up for marathons as their first race: most people aren't prepared. That it worked for you is great, but you
by wpietri 12y ago
It's basically the same reason people shouldn't sign up for marathons as their first race: most people aren't prepared. That it worked for you is great, but you shouldn't mistake your experience for the general case. I have a lot of friends who do retreats like this, and they universally recommend that most people work their way up.
Regarding point #3, for those who would like guidance, I recommend finding a local meditation group. There are lots, and there are many different styles.
- colechristensen 12y agoIt might be better to recommend a 1,2, or 3 day retreat which are also common and more approachable (and possible) to many people.
- wpietri 12y agoThat's definitely a more reasonable recommendation, although it's probably not the one I'd make myself. Some people take to meditation quite naturally; for some it's a real struggle. For the inexperienced but curious, about the most I'd generally recommend is stopping by some meditation group for a single sit. As an example, the San Francisco Zen Center's farm, Green Gulch, has a Sunday program that's quite nice: http://www.sfzc.org/ggf/display.asp?catid=3,123&pageid=239 http://www.sfzc.org/ggf/display.asp?catid=3,123&pageid=239 Gentle instruction, a short lecture, and then the option of casual tea and conversation. If people find themselves comfortable enough with a single sit that they're saying, "Gosh, I want 3 days of this," then more power to 'em. But that definitely wasn't my first experience. I needed a more gradual path.
- kamakazizuru 12y agoI think each one has their own mileage - I was just refuting the parent's claim that you "should" do x or y - I think if you've considered it for a while and think you can stick through it - there's no harm in trying a 10 day retreat. Just as there's no harm in trying a marathon if you're generally fit. Worst case you drop out / slow down.
- wpietri 12y agoThat is an interesting theory, but you are definitely wrong about the marathon part. I know a number of people who have harmed themselves by attempting a marathon as their first race, a couple permanently. My concern about the harm of an unprepared person taking a 10-day class is different. Most of the people I know who went from doing nothing to trying a marathon are no longer runners. Either the difficulty and pain or the experience of failure were enough to dissuade them from taking up a regular running practice. If someone jumps into a 10-day retreat with no prior experience, I would be concerned about something similar happening to them.
- ca98am79 12y agoIt's not like a marathon - preparation isn't really going to help you much. It's much more like "meditation bootcamp" - breaking down is part of the building process.