4 ms·
As a result you have prosecutors doing what they do best, throwing everything at the wall and seeing what sticks. The problem with throwing everything at the wa
by chongli 12y ago
As a result you have prosecutors doing what they do best, throwing everything at the wall and seeing what sticks. The problem with throwing everything at the wall is that defendants are more inclined to accept a reasonable plea rather than face the unknown.
This is a symptom of a much greater problem in our society: plea bargaining and the legislation built to take advantage of it. Plea bargaining is routinely used to extract guilty pleas from those too intimidated or otherwise unable to adequately defend themselves. It is profoundly unjust at its core. Its proponents tout it as a way to save money and reduce the burden on our courts. Since when has saving money been a fundamental pillar of justice?
If you ask me, we should do away with pleas altogether. All defendants would automatically be tried as if not guilty. Prosecution would likewise be compulsory. We would then have to rewrite most of our laws to reduce the ridiculous number of prosecutions that would result from the above changes. This would empower judges to do what they have been trained to do: discover the factual record and independently assess the case against the defendant.