3 ms·
We need to separate the process of deciding if a paper should be published in a journal from the process of reviewing a paper. Reviewers (I have been one many t
by danieltillett 12y ago
We need to separate the process of deciding if a paper should be published in a journal from the process of reviewing a paper. Reviewers (I have been one many times) are asked to do two things:
1. Give an opinion as to value of the paper and if it should be published in journal x
2. Point out flaws or suggest improvements to the paper.
These two activities are not really connected to each other. The decision to publish or not in a journal is an editorial decision that reviewers should not be making. I am happy to point out flaws or suggest improvements, but who am I to make a judgment on the value an article to a journal? If the science is sound (but boring) does that make it less worthwhile of publication?
One advantage of separating these two processes is it would enable reviewers to communicate directly with the authors to ask questions or get more information. As a reviewer I have many time wanted to fire off a quick email to the authors to resolve something that I was unclear on, but the need to make the process anonymous (so I can pass judgement on the value of the paper) means everything has to go back via the editor. This makes it impossible to open a dialog with the authors and get the best result for science.