3 ms·
I didn't submit this as a means to spark yet another debate on HN about gender dynamics or political correctness, but an example of a well-handled controversy b
by danso 12y ago
I didn't submit this as a means to spark yet another debate on HN about gender dynamics or political correctness, but an example of a well-handled controversy by an open-source maintainer.
Let's ignore the details of the controversy. What we have here is someone who has made a useful gem and, after a couple of years, is told out of the blue that it's somewhat offensive. Someone else then submits a pull-request that "fixes" the problem. Meanwhile, the Github issues section has been basically vote-brigaded into a trollfest, to the point where many people would've just shut down the repo or not attempted any rational thinking because of how offensive and standoffish the debate had become.
But instead, the OP accepts the pull request and writes a very level-headed post about why he both agrees and disagrees with the sexism complaint. Even though such a complaint is one that he could've taken personally, he doesn't, and instead, he applies empathy and rationality when making his decision.
Whether you like the outcome or not, I think this is a prime example of civil discourse and action in OSS: a level-headed maintainer, and someone who makes a pull-request as proof of concept.
- throwaway43232 12y agoTotally agree. I think the maintainer here did a stellar job. The only thing that I don't think was considered in his response, and is the reason I came here to comment, is that I don't think we're fully thinking through the unintended consequences of placating everyone who is offended by something no matter how minor. A environment that is overly sensitive and where people are easily offended is an environment that is not welcoming of people on the aspie-autistic end of the spectrum, especially on the internet where you don't know whether someone is neurotypical or not. People who are neurotypical tend to assume that everyone else is neurotypical as well. Open-source was and has always been a place where those on the aspie-autistic end of the spectrum can and do excel. Elevating feelings over code and being technically correct creates and environment that is fraught for those people who generally have less empathy and don't really get offended themselves. Between making open source welcoming to people who are neurotypical and making it welcome to people on the aspie-autistic end of the spectrum, we all lose by favoring the former. The overwhelming majority of truly valuable contributions in our field are done by people who are neurologically aspie-autistic.
- dragonwriter 12y ago> The overwhelming majority of truly valuable contributions in our field are done by people who are neurologically aspie-autistic. [citation needed]
- throwaway43232 12y agoIt's anecodotal based on many years of experience in the industry, but if you have real data or even many anecdotes that contradict my observations, I'm keen on hearing them. I'm more than happy to accept being wrong here if I am.
- saraid216 12y ago> Elevating feelings over code and being technically correct creates and environment that is fraught for those people who generally have less empathy and don't really get offended themselves. Except that's what you're doing here. There isn't a technical issue under discussion; there's a discussion over feelings. And while you certainly have the right to ask that your feelings be respected in order to offend another's, you really can't pretend objectivity. What you can do, and have done, is claim that aspie sensitivities are more important than female ones because aspies are somehow a greater contribution to the world. The interesting thing is the implication here that aspie sensitivities are likely to be sexist, because otherwise, there would be no conflict between the different sensitivities. In making an apparent defense of this group, you've managed to pretty thoroughly condemn them. So... good job?
- throwaway43232 12y ago> What you can do, and have done, is claim that aspie sensitivities are more important than female ones because aspies are somehow a greater contribution to the world. Not at all what I claimed. I'm talking about overly sensitive people, not women. I know tons and tons and tons of people, women included, who are not overly sensitive and who are able to handle situations like an adult and focus on the task at hand, which in the case of open source is building software and writing code. It's not a therapy session. It's about building things and that is more important than feelings. Your feelings are my distraction. I'm actually the go-between at work between those people think are assholes and some people that are overly sensitive. I quietly hate the role I play and wish I didn't have to waste time trying to protect people from their emotions. It's exhausting. The overly sensitive people often hijack technical discussions and try to make those discussions about something that matters to them personally and that makes the discussion no longer about the code and technical matters that the group is trying to solve. Furthermore, just as many overly-sensitive men as women are responsible for hijacking technical discussions to talk about feelings. In fact, I probably witness men being overly sensitive about some social issue with greater frequency (probably due to base rates in our industry). I also didn't claim that aspies tend to be sexist, but that they tend to either not place importance on how their word choice might be interpreted or they might not even be aware that their word choice did offend. It's mentally taxing and expensive to deal with overly sensitive people who lose focus on the task at hand because they feel offended or hurt. Terms like "microagressions"[0] aren't even part of the aspie vocabulary. Due to my own morbid curiosity, I spent a bunch of time reading about microagressions and I was like, "yeah, a bunch of these types of things happen to me all the time too. What's the big fucking deal?". I don't think anything of them. People who dwell on them are only blocking themselves. All I could think of when reading them was Bob Newhart's skit "Stop It!"[1]. It's bad enough that people do that to themselves, but the people who are vocal about them are forcing others to dwell on their own personal issues, wasting everyone's time. That's exactly what Sharp did by calling out Torvalds. Calling Torvalds out and playing the victim card was a massive waste of everyone else's time and did nothing to contribute to the technical discussion at the time. If people want similar project with different culture to exist, there is a more civil solution, go write a project from scratch or fork a project written by assholes and recruit all the overly-sensitive people to participate in trying to make it better. I wish you the best of luck, but what you shouldn't do is come into anyone else's house that they built and call them out on how they behave in their house. [0] http://microaggressions.tumblr.com/ http://microaggressions.tumblr.com/ [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ow0lr63y4Mw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ow0lr63y4Mw