3 ms·
Is there any version of this "right" that would actually be sensible? I mean many countries do provide some recourse if you prove libelous statements were publi
by EGreg 12y ago
Is there any version of this "right" that would actually be sensible? I mean many countries do provide some recourse if you prove libelous statements were published. So the machinery exists in some form, and hasn't led to a lot of abuse. Libel, though, requires proving that the statements are false.
- benologist 12y agoBy limiting it to libel you are defeating the purpose of the right to be forgotten. If you are charged with something and found innocent you should have the right to not be forever associated with it in search results for your name. If you are the victim of something you should be able to move on without every potential employer and partner building an image skewed by that moment.
- sailfast 12y agoJust because you remove it from Google doesn't mean it didn't happen. Removing it from Google also doesn't result in your employer having an open mind about your past history. Making it easier to find something does not mean it won't be found. If you're a defendant in a case and proven innocent - that's on the record. If you're a victim of something and your name has been released to the public - also on the record. If it's a public record I support all efforts to make that data as easily accessible as possible. Preventing public discovery of an existing record does no one a service.
- chc 12y agoThe fact that that exercise of the "right to be forgotten" won't completely protect you from facts about the past is a red herring. Security is almost never perfect. Security is mostly about making something generally impractical to do. This is similar — a dedicated snoop will probably be able to find the dirt, but it won't be readily apparent to everyone who types your name into the world's most typed-into box.
- sailfast 12y agoTotally understand and security by obscurity is definitely possible and effective, though difficult for media and the internet. That said, if something is legitimately public, why would we not want to make it easily accessible "using the world's most typed-into box"? Why would we prevent someone from developing an effective way to make that data available to the public? What differentiates something with your name on it from all other data? (I'm not talking about private data here that you entered or were promised would be shared in a private context from, say, a profile or payment information standpoint) This new "right" seems completely random and out of left field. It doesn't really have anything to do with privacy. I don't agree that it is a right because to me, rights make sense across the board. This one only kind of makes sense in a narrow context and when applied broadly doesn't work at all, and infringes on all the others.
- benologist 12y agoIt's a massive privacy issue - you can change in very personal, significant ways without Google etc updating the person they present you as being - your political beliefs, your gender and sexuality, controversial opinions etc. There are many contexts where these and outdated versions of you shouldn't be the most-available, most-presented information about you.
- benologist 12y agoJust because something happened doesn't make it relevant or truthful in all contexts forever.
- chc 12y agoThe "right to be forgotten" is based on the principle that people can be wronged both by true and false statements about them. Here is the best sense I can make of the dispute here: It is obvious that there are many true things you can say about most people that would be harmful to them. Part of the purpose of the law is to give people a recourse outside of violence against people who wrong them. So the question is, when you say harmful-but-true things about somebody, is there a greater concern that overrides their ability to seek recourse? The US would generally (but certainly not always) say "yes," while the EU tends to say "maybe."
- duskwuff 12y agoI can see a case for a very limited "right to be forgotten", restricted by: * Time. You should only be able to request the removal of information that is old -- like, perhaps at least 10 or 15 years. Forgetting takes time, after all. * Scope. Anything that's a matter of public record should be completely off limits to have "forgotten". If you want it to go away, you have to get it removed from the public records first. * Target. High-profile individuals (celebrities, elected officials, etc.) live highly public lives by choice. They should be fully exempt.