3 ms·
The idea of a "right" to compel other people to destroy information is comically absurd. Obviously, 99% of the people who might abuse such a "right" are PR gro
by wyager 12y ago
The idea of a "right" to compel other people to destroy information is comically absurd.
Obviously, 99% of the people who might abuse such a "right" are PR groups working for corrupt politicians and corporations; there's no way this is going to be useful for the average person.
This is also a huge pain in the ass technically. It is simply very hard for most sites to enforce arbitrary censorship, and we know how wonderful DMCA takedown requests have been. At least with DMCA requests and more common censorship laws (against proscribed political beliefs, pornography, etc.) there's a fairly limited scope of things that site operators have to worry about.
And this is censorship; that much is clear. You are forbidden from speaking about people who have the wherewithal to leverage this "right". These aren't even anti-slander laws; under the "right to be forgotten", you are forbidden from making even perfectly true statements about someone.
- lnanek2 12y agoI don't like the right to be forgotten implementation and social implications either, although we do have something slightly related in California that does work. Web sites you login to have to have a privacy policy, profile page, and the ability to change or delete your profile. So I think the Europeans are nuts with their deleting news articles, but I do believe the California system where you can delete anything you yourself put in is fine.
- freshflowers 12y agoThis entire argument is pure FUD. It doesn't apply to politicians, who have chosen to be public figures, and it doesn't apply to corporations because they aren't people. And nothing is forbidden. The right to be forgotten is opt-out. You can publish anything you like, and unlike DMCA you can let any dispute go all the way up the legal chain. It has absolutely nothing at all to do with censorship.
- comrh 12y agoI agree with you but if this was a thing in America this: > doesn't apply to corporations because they aren't people. could be a problem post Citizens United couldn't it?
- wyager 12y ago>It doesn't apply to politicians "I'm not a politician! I'm just a humble police commissioner." > it doesn't apply to corporations "I'm not a corporation! I'm just a humble executive." >And nothing is forbidden. The right to be forgotten is opt-out. What is this supposed to mean? This is clearly not the case. Websites cannot opt-out of following these requests. >unlike DMCA you can let any dispute go all the way up the legal chain. Oh great, so I get some semblance of due process before being censored? >It has absolutely nothing at all to do with censorship. Explain to me how preventing me from saying true things about certain people is not censorship.