6 ms·
‘Right to Be Forgotten’ Should Apply Worldwide, E.U. Panel Says
- cheepin 12y agoI think I speak for America and the rest of the world when I say that the EU should stop trying to boss around foreign companies. This was ridiculous the first time when it only applied to EU, but now it's pure insanity.
- ProAm 12y ago> I think I speak for America and the rest of the world when I say Ummm no you don't.
- dragonwriter 12y ago> I think I speak for America and the rest of the world when I say There is literally nothing that could follow this beginning and not be absurd, including (but not limited to) what actually follows it in your post.
- vixen99 12y agoWell I think there is: it's :"the EU should stop trying to boss around foreign companies". Perhaps you can explain why that is absurd because it's prefaced by an (agreed) absurdity?
- potatolicious 12y agoAll international laws, treaties, and agreements are "bossing around foreign [people|companies]" We have extradition treaties, peace treaties, copyright treaties, trade agreements, etc etc, all of which present restrictions on what private individuals and corporations can and cannot do. The notion that countries will seek to gain international adherence to its desired rules is anything but absurd. The only absurdity here is what's actually being proposed - so let's talk about that, instead of some notion that countries should not pursue international cooperation. There's also a bit of hypocrisy when claiming to "speak for America", considering this is a country that has literally gone to war in order to "boss around foreign [people|companies]" - I'm not even talking about Iraq, look up the sordid history of the United Fruit Company and its relationship to Latin American interventionism.
- j4meserljoness 12y ago>The notion that countries will seek to gain international adherence to its desired rules is anything but absurd Strongly disagree. Sovereignty exists so that my rules don't apply to you.
- tormeh 12y agoPlot twist: By day he's the US' envoy to Brussels and by night he's secretary general of the UN. He is..... Speak-on-Behalf-Man!
- dkbrk 12y agoI take it you don't appreciate the irony in light of the US trying to enforce its copyright laws internationally.
- thieving_magpie 12y agoCan't we just focus on the issue posted in this thread? Or do we need to address all inequities in the world before we're allowed to have an opinion on a global "right to be forgotten"?
- EGreg 12y agoI think I speak for America and the rest of the workd when I admit we are diverse.
- liotier 12y ago> I think I speak for America and the rest of the world when I say that the EU should stop trying to boss around foreign companies. True - it is America's job !
- freshflowers 12y agoBecause the rights of American companies to exploit EU citizens should come before the civil rights of those citizens? That's sanity to you? If that's the American way, I would like to opt out.
- happyscrappy 12y agoI think the EU would be more comfortable switching to Baidu. The censorship is built in.
- madez 12y agoThe government of the United States of (Central-North) America also forces foreign companies to give up information that is not stored in that specific country. Truth is that every country can demand whatever it wants from companies operating within it. That's part of a concept called national sovereignty. If the company doesn't like it they can stop doing business in that country. Of course countries should try to cooperate but that's simply not always possible.
- WildUtah 12y agoI think I speak for the rest of the world when I say that America should stop bossing around foreign companies and forcing them to turn over foreign personal data to American secret spy agencies.
- xacaxulu 12y agoKeyword: think
- penprog 12y agoI think this is good, I think people should be able to delete their online presence when they turn 18. The way the internet is now, it's too easy to screw up your own life.
- ominous 12y agoI can't agree with this. I see erasing bits of the internet that don't belong to you the same way I'd see asking for people to forget memories.
- ProAm 12y agoExcept a lot of the time recorded history is one-sided and often out of context. People should have a right to a reasonable amount of privacy. Especially children when they do not really understand the mistakes they make while growing up (adults too). Too many witch hunts come out of half-truths and manipulated 'evidence' and facts.
- EGreg 12y agoIf you see this as expanding libel laws, including the ability to compel publishers to take down or retract libelous statements, then maybe there is some machinery in place. There is an objective criterion, at least - someone was under 18, someone definitely lied, etc. But like any machinery it can be abused. And expanding it will increase the potential for abuse.
- andrewfong 12y agoExcept a lot of the time recorded history is quite accurate and in context, and people are using privacy or allegations of falsehood as an excuse to engage in censorship. That's not to imply that all of the info out there is truthful and of legitimate public interest. But the right to be forgotten can and has in fact been abused.
- ProAm 12y agoI agree, and definitely do not think its a perfect solution. But I feel that people who are innocent deserve this ability, sort of akin to the statement: " it's better that 1000 guilty men go free than one innocent man be imprisoned"
- wyager 12y agoThe idea of a "right" to compel other people to destroy information is comically absurd. Obviously, 99% of the people who might abuse such a "right" are PR groups working for corrupt politicians and corporations; there's no way this is going to be useful for the average person. This is also a huge pain in the ass technically. It is simply very hard for most sites to enforce arbitrary censorship, and we know how wonderful DMCA takedown requests have been. At least with DMCA requests and more common censorship laws (against proscribed political beliefs, pornography, etc.) there's a fairly limited scope of things that site operators have to worry about. And this is censorship; that much is clear. You are forbidden from speaking about people who have the wherewithal to leverage this "right". These aren't even anti-slander laws; under the "right to be forgotten", you are forbidden from making even perfectly true statements about someone.
- lnanek2 12y agoI don't like the right to be forgotten implementation and social implications either, although we do have something slightly related in California that does work. Web sites you login to have to have a privacy policy, profile page, and the ability to change or delete your profile. So I think the Europeans are nuts with their deleting news articles, but I do believe the California system where you can delete anything you yourself put in is fine.
- freshflowers 12y agoThis entire argument is pure FUD. It doesn't apply to politicians, who have chosen to be public figures, and it doesn't apply to corporations because they aren't people. And nothing is forbidden. The right to be forgotten is opt-out. You can publish anything you like, and unlike DMCA you can let any dispute go all the way up the legal chain. It has absolutely nothing at all to do with censorship.
- comrh 12y agoI agree with you but if this was a thing in America this: > doesn't apply to corporations because they aren't people. could be a problem post Citizens United couldn't it?
- liotier 12y ago‘Censorship’ Should Apply Worldwide, E.U. Panel Says
- freshflowers 12y agoThrowing the word 'censorship' around in civil rights issues is as cheap and meaningless as using terrorism and child abuse as an excuse for privacy violations.
- woah 12y agoWhy? It's a term that applies to the concept in question. The other things you mentioned are, in contrast, scaremongering.
- liotier 12y agoAs Wikipedia's definition goes: "Censorship is the suppression of speech, public communication or other information which may be considered objectionable, harmful, sensitive, politically incorrect or inconvenient as determined by governments, media outlets, authorities or other groups or institutions". So, how is "Right to be forgotten" not censorship ? As for the balance between protection of individuals vs. transparency, laws already exists in many countries to protect the individuals. Powerless individuals are not the beneficiaries of the "Right to be forgotten" legislation : those who use (and abuse) it already are corporations and powerful individuals...
- j4meserljoness 12y agoCalling the 'right to be forgotten' bullshit a civil rights issue demeans real civil rights issues, and there are plenty.
- droope 12y agoSometimes films get adapted in order to be suitable for younger audiences, and that is called censorship because that is the meaning of the word. http://www.pictureshowman.com/articles_genhist_censorship.cfm http://www.pictureshowman.com/articles_genhist_censorship.cf... In New Zealand, the law that "enforces" this is called the "censorship" law. http://www.censor.org.nz/classification-law/censorship-law-in-nz.html http://www.censor.org.nz/classification-law/censorship-law-i...
- EGreg 12y agoIs there any version of this "right" that would actually be sensible? I mean many countries do provide some recourse if you prove libelous statements were published. So the machinery exists in some form, and hasn't led to a lot of abuse. Libel, though, requires proving that the statements are false.
- benologist 12y agoBy limiting it to libel you are defeating the purpose of the right to be forgotten. If you are charged with something and found innocent you should have the right to not be forever associated with it in search results for your name. If you are the victim of something you should be able to move on without every potential employer and partner building an image skewed by that moment.
- sailfast 12y agoJust because you remove it from Google doesn't mean it didn't happen. Removing it from Google also doesn't result in your employer having an open mind about your past history. Making it easier to find something does not mean it won't be found. If you're a defendant in a case and proven innocent - that's on the record. If you're a victim of something and your name has been released to the public - also on the record. If it's a public record I support all efforts to make that data as easily accessible as possible. Preventing public discovery of an existing record does no one a service.
- chc 12y agoThe fact that that exercise of the "right to be forgotten" won't completely protect you from facts about the past is a red herring. Security is almost never perfect. Security is mostly about making something generally impractical to do. This is similar — a dedicated snoop will probably be able to find the dirt, but it won't be readily apparent to everyone who types your name into the world's most typed-into box.
- sailfast 12y ago
- smm2000 12y agoI am waiting for Tuvalu to issue law saying that for $100 you have right to delete any information from Google worldwide.
- sailfast 12y agoRight to be forgotten, to me, implies a right to rewrite history. If we extend this to other media - "Right to remove all mentions of my name from indexes in published books" does this make any sense at all? If anything, you already have the right to solicit a retraction and or takedown to fix the problem. You're not asking for the source material to be removed from the web root content, because that would be crazy and a violation of rights, so you're just asking for the revealing of its existence to be removed? Similar to requests from users to "change the way that thing looks on the chart", the reason why it looks that way is because the data is there. Either change the data, or live with the picture it presents. Sure, you can blame the graph for its approach to displaying the data, but removal is a clear half-measure. When it's clear a full measure fix is a terrible idea, the half-measure is probably also at least half as terrible, or maybe / .5 as terrible depending on which "law" you use.
- happyscrappy 12y agoThis has zero chance and reflects poorly on the EU.
- probably_wrong 12y agoWell, it might reflect poorly from the States maybe. I totally agree with the EU, and I'm willing to guess that so do most Europeans. I'm pretty sure this question could be used as a reasonably reliable predictor of nationality.
- happyscrappy 12y agoThis has zero chance. Zero. Hopefully they are just grandstanding for their home audience and are not as clueless as they sound.
- probably_wrong 12y agoThere are two issues here: 1_ the EU trying to convince Google to delete data they are allowed to have outside the EU. That won't work. 2_ the ruling that Google must make certain data unavailable within the boundaries of the EU or pay the consequences. Simply stating "we did, buy then users used the wrong two letters (domain) and accessed it anyway" is a poor excuse, and I think the EU won't take it. I can imagine Google blocking results based on IP (like they currently do with music videos on YouTube) as a reasonable compromise the EU can enforce. It does not account for proxies, of course, but it's a start.
- onestone 12y agoAs an European, I find this "right" to be forgotten completely ridiculous.
- Reebles 12y agoI understand the need for something like this. The right to delete all Google+, Facebook, and ad tracker network stored data etc. seems reasonable. The right to limit search engine discoverability of 3rd party published information seems to be a step too far. I'm not sure where you draw the line, but there does seem to at least be a line somewhere in there.
- Animats 12y agoThere are a lot of big-name crooks who would like to rewrite history. I see this regularly on Wikipedia's conflict of interest notice board. In the last year, four different rich guys with old felony convictions have paid editors trying to make their criminal history go away. In each case, they've failed on Wikipedia. With a "right to be forgotten", they could litigate over that. Even if they had a weak case, it could become dangerous to refer to the criminal history of anyone with money. There's already been one lawsuit on Wikipedia, alleging defamation for going over someone's past rather than merely echoing what came out of their PR firm. I was one of the people listed in the lawsuit, but the plaintiff backed down after a threat of a countersuit.
- thrush 12y agoSlightly related, but what are thoughts on using internet harassment for extortion purposes or personal attacks. In many ways, the technology and policies we'd use to prevent this harassment could be frightfully similar to technology that allows censorship. Interesting related article: http://www.troyhunt.com/2014/11/ransom-is-new-black-increasing-trend-of.html http://www.troyhunt.com/2014/11/ransom-is-new-black-increasi...
- happyscrappy 12y agoThis is such a great idea that Europeans are flagging it to suppress a discussion.
- freshflowers 12y agoThe deliberate misrepresentation and/or willful ignorance about what the "right to be forgotten" means is pathetic. I really expect better from HN, regardless of whether people agree with it or not. Just some points: - Politicians, public figures, celebrities and any kind of information that is the public or historic interest does not fall under the right to be forgotten. - Corporations, governments etcetera do not fall under the right to be forgotten. - There is no DMCA-like process. This notion is the result of Google's disinformation campaign and the deliberately flawed process Google implemented, like a child throwing a tantrum. - This has nothing to do with censorship. There is nothing pre-emptive about it. Individuals have to actively make each and every request. Any request for removal can be taken all the way up the legal chain. Yes, there is a chilling effect risk in the implementation of the right to be forgotten. Possibly to the point where the right itself needs a much clearer definition. Possibly even to the point where the conclusion is that it is impossible to implement without harmful side effects that outweigh the benefits. Those are valid discussions. But so far I've seen very little of that discussion on HN, just a lot of FUD and outright BS.
- Oletros 12y ago> - Politicians, public figures, celebrities and any kind of information that is the public or historic interest does not fall under the right to be forgotten. I have read those claims some times, can you please direct me to were in the law is said this?
- WildUtah 12y agoIn all the discussion about Silicon Valley and why no place else has been able to have quite so much success in high tech, subtle cultural issues can be underemphasized because they aren't easily quantified. This attitude toward freedom of speech and data in the EU is one reason why startups don't prosper as well there. For a society to allow and even encourage independent people to create new ways to collaborate with data is risky to existing powers. Most societies place restrictions on who can know or say things and then impose severe consequences on the people about whom those things are said. Sometimes the restrictions and consequences are informal. There may be a strong norm against sharing data or gossiping or spying or publishing. There may be a strong sense of reputation or face or a presumption that bad things said about you make you a bad person and unemployable. The EU is a place where people have lived with the idea that central authorities can tell individuals what to say or not say for a long time. The large news and data institutions and churches have strong links to the state and individuals are not expected to be able to make choices about information for themselves. Political parties are routinely banned and prosecuted solely for disagreeing with ruling parties; elected officials have been prosecuted and jailed in France and the Netherlands in this decade merely for being leaders of the minority parties in their national and EU legislatures. [0] A certain confidence that anything officially published is endorsed by powerful people lingers weakly as a result. People don't like small companies, startups, individuals controlling data as a result. China and Japan are the same, though each in its own way, of course, just as each European culture is different. But America is an outlier. We trust our government and newspapers less. We expect authorities' pronouncements to have less effect on our prospects and reputations. We share data freely and expect that people can gossip about us freely with limited consequences. We even expect a certain amount of lying to go on without being prohibited, though it upsets us more because we've developed stronger norms against it than nations where authorities are expected to have the power routinely to deceive the people like the EU. And in tech, where information is everything, that cultural approbation for data is deeply though subtly influential. It's one of the many things that make US startups and especially Silicon Valley ones more successful. Which isn't to day that this EU decision is a bad thing for startups. It's bad for Google, but that's not all startups. It creates an opening for an American company to provide a search engine that fills in Google's EU gaps. EU companies might be able to find ways to exploit it, too. It does reflect one of the cultural advantages of Silicon Valley, though. Along with the esteem for entrepreneurs, openness to failure, flexible job market, and network effects, freedom of speech is a business advantage in tech. [0]http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trial_of_Geert_Wilders http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trial_of_Geert_Wilders http://www.theguardian.com/world/2013/jul/02/marine-le-pen-immunity-lifted http://www.theguardian.com/world/2013/jul/02/marine-le-pen-i...