4 ms·
The stats presented by the article are very myopic. Bikes are mobile objects that frequently travel between areas covered by multiple precincts. Rather than l
by uptown 12y ago
The stats presented by the article are very myopic. Bikes are mobile objects that frequently travel between areas covered by multiple precincts. Rather than looking solely at the 5th precinct, they arguably should have presented a wider view of the city's records on bicycle activity. When you do that, it paints a very different picture of some of the statistics.
For instance - "cyclist accidents that caused deaths" : 2013: 0, 2014: 0
Jill Tarlov was killed by a biker in September:
http://gothamist.com/2014/09/22/jill_tarlov_central_park.php http://gothamist.com/2014/09/22/jill_tarlov_central_park.php
Irving Schachter was killed by a biker in August:
http://gothamist.com/2014/08/14/cyclist_kills_jogger.php http://gothamist.com/2014/08/14/cyclist_kills_jogger.php
- lfuller 12y agoThat's not relevant to the discussion. This article was disputing a claim that "the 5th Pct. had a 115% increase in bicycle collisions this year", not that NYC in general had an increase.
- uptown 12y agoUnderstood. But the premise of the article asks if the 5th Precinct plans to "start ticketing more cyclists". The tweet didn't say that. It said they'll be enforcing violations, which is what you expect police officers to do with laws that are on the books. You're right - maybe the stats are bad, and the post is right to ask for clarification. But the post assumes the tweet means they'll change their enforcement tactics, and I don't read that in this tweet.
- oh_sigh 12y agoYou should be directing your criticism at the NYPD, which is the group that put forward the claim that there was a 115% increase in bicycle accidents in the 5th precinct.