3 ms·
I find it very strange that one of the most important tests that US students take is a bombardment of multiple choice questions. I find it very strange too big
by barry-cotter 12y ago
I find it very strange that one of the most important tests that US students take is a bombardment of multiple choice questions.
I find it very strange too big that doesn't mean it doesn't work. One of the interesting findings from the psychometrics of intelligence testing/g is that given sufficient motivation all tests are culture fair. You can work really hard to make a test that is approximately as fair to chimps as humans (Raven's Progressive Matrices) or you can decide on a corpus of culturally bound knowledge and publish the requirements and given sufficient preparation time the rank ordering will be approximately the same.
I'm presuming you're European as well, right? The truth is the SAT/GRE/GMAT/LSAT/MCAT are so highly g loaded that they're good IQ tests and our school leaving/college entrance exams are a combination IQ test and conscientiousness test. There will also be small effects for pitch perception in music but seriously the poor reliability of any one SAT question is irrelevant given enough of them. In the limit statistics don't lie. Not that there's anything wrong with complex summative exams, I'll support anything from economics quals to continental philosophy as the subject to be examined for rankings because for most purposes it's the rankings, not the substance that's important.
The method used here is not entirely problem-free either but it's a whole lot more practical than having a long string of multiple choice questions where you have a 25% chance by guessing and you get to know all the possible answers. This is not really representative of what you need in life or what you'll encounter in later studies in College/University.
Practicality is a false idol. Higher (and lower) education is more sorting/signalling than training. This can be blatant like Iran/Japan/Korea/USA where what university you got into is much more important than what you studied or what grade you got in the end, middling like the UK where there's a first tier (Oxbridge), a second (Russell Group) and also rans or other varieties like Germany (all universities are approximately equal, grades are approximately equivalent) or France (like Germany mostly with the grandes ecoles as very specialised high prestige schools). Some courses (ones that teach useful knowledge independent of ranking, like nursing or engineering) will have strangely higher salary averages for low prestige universities than one would expect, and the range for the comparable graduates of better universities will be oddly compressed.
Education is underrated, schooling the opposite.