3 ms·
> Foreign exams: "you have an chance of scoring a few points even if the final answer is incorrect". In this respect, the foreign exams are giving you credit fo
by scrollaway 12y ago
> Foreign exams: "you have an chance of scoring a few points even if the final answer is incorrect". In this respect, the foreign exams are giving you credit for being wrong but well-intentioned. Is that a desirable quality? That you know what to do, but you can't do it in practice? IMO giving credit for partial answers to basic knowledge questions is a highly dubious practice.
None would give points for something that is wrong. They would, however, give points for using the correct technique in getting to the answer (but maybe something was missed, or miscalculated, etc).
This is not being given "partial credit for being wrong", it's being given credit for having the technique to get to the answers you seek. In an age where data retention is a much less desirable skill than adaptation and the ability to find answers (what with Google existing), I think it's an extremely important point.
I think you are seeing the SATs in a good light because they succeed at doing what they are set to do: have students retain a bunch of information for a while. What they most definitely don't do is teach students how to think outside the box, think for themselves, approach problems they haven't encountered before and approach problems nobody has encountered before.
- learnstats2 12y ago> What they most definitely don't do is teach students how to think outside the box, think for themselves, approach problems they haven't encountered before and approach problems nobody has encountered before. OK, but how can this be achieved by examination? This is really not what exams are about and it's a mistake to try and fit those goals into an exam space. Exams are considered unfair if they have an unlimited scope. When I said the SAT gives more flexibility to teach off-syllabus topics compared to other international equivalents, this offers you a space where you can target those blue sky goals. I don't criticise your goals, but exams are never where those goals are reached. So, I suggest we should minimise the concentration on exams. This is something the SAT system does (relatively) successfully - also because it is completed long before the end of high school.
- scrollaway 12y agoI don't work in the field so I won't argue it but this sounds like the root of our disagreement. A lot of people believe exams should in fact prioritize these more abstract skills over raw stuffage-of-data-into-brain. You say exams are not about that and it may be so, but I'm not convinced it's not possible to make them about that. A giant list of multiple choice questions won't achieve it though, not any better than the briggs-myers anyway.
- learnstats2 12y agoI recommend you attempt the SAT Math Subject Tests, if you haven't already.