3 ms·

Why will it be huge in India? For textbooks, typically you can get cheaper south-asia only editions. Many engineering books go for $10 for example. Newspapers a

Why will it be huge in India? For textbooks, typically you can get cheaper south-asia only editions. Many engineering books go for $10 for example. Newspapers are about $10-$15 per year. So I don't see why this will be particularly hit in India?

plinkplonk 17y ago
"For textbooks, typically you can get cheaper south-asia only editions. Many engineering books go for $10 for example. Newspapers are about $10-$15 per year. " Ok Why don't you find me an Indian Edition of "Coders At Work?". ;-) More seriously you are (somewhat) right. Some books (most popular technical books eventually become available in cheap Indian editions. If all books available on the Kindle had a cheap Indian edition, your argument would have merit. There are two advantages to the Kindle over waiting for the Indian Edition of a textbook (if it ever comes out), time and convenience. First technical books, there are large numbers of technical books that are not available in Indian Edition. Buying from Amazon isn't an option because the postage costs ramps up the price. (the "2 day" shipping option doubles the price. For heavier books Amazon ads an extra 10 $ to ship to India.The lesser options often result in the book not being delivered because it got "lost" somewhere in transit). So if you order from Amazon (and many many people do, in spite of the delays and the cost , because they have no chpoice), the added postage fee more than cancels any discount. Often the Indian edition books are released upto a year or more after the foreign edition is released and the paper and print quality is really sucky (to make it cheap I imagine.) Give me an option of instant purchase (today you have to order books form India and wait for weeks to see how important this is) and I'd choose that in flash. Indian booksellers often take months to deliver a book not in the store inventory. Indian booksellers suck. Even an "Amazon India" would destroy them if it existed. And as for textbooks specifically only a minor subset of the good textbooks in say Mechanical Engineering is available in Indian Edition. The situation is better for "Perl in 21 days" type software books. For example Peter Norvig's "Artificial Intelligence A Modern Approach " 3d edition is slated for release at the end of 2009 in the USA. I don't expect to see it in a cheap Indian Edition till the end of 2010. I maintain that if the Kindle works well in India in terms of connectivity and so on (this remains to be seen), it will be a huge disruptive force in bookselling. Indian publishing houses are still in the 19th century as far as technology and distribution are concerned. Some of my friends were trying to set up an e-publishing startup with a kindle like device and did some market research on this. (They didn't get funding which is another story entirely).
- codedivine 17y ago
  Well, at my university, the common solution was to go to the library, borrow the book and then get it photocopied. Copyright infringement? Probably. Cost effective: yes. I don't know a whole lot of students in India who will spend $260 for their textbooks over their entire undergrad let alone spend $260 on a ebook reader and then spend a lot of money buying books. However, kindle may become popular with professionals perhaps.
  - dagw 17y ago
    I used several photocopied books when at university. Basically someone would run off one copy of the relevant chapters, then we'd take that to a copy shop and they'd run off a dozen copies of it double sided and bind it nicely. A lot of people did it and no one ever said anything.
    - codedivine 17y ago
      Precisely. I think cost matters to students more than convenience in most cases.

plinkplonk 17y ago

"For textbooks, typically you can get cheaper south-asia only editions. Many engineering books go for $10 for example. Newspapers are about $10-$15 per year. " Ok Why don't you find me an Indian Edition of "Coders At Work?". ;-) More seriously you are (somewhat) right. Some books (most popular technical books eventually become available in cheap Indian editions. If all books available on the Kindle had a cheap Indian edition, your argument would have merit. There are two advantages to the Kindle over waiting for the Indian Edition of a textbook (if it ever comes out), time and convenience. First technical books, there are large numbers of technical books that are not available in Indian Edition. Buying from Amazon isn't an option because the postage costs ramps up the price. (the "2 day" shipping option doubles the price. For heavier books Amazon ads an extra 10 $ to ship to India.The lesser options often result in the book not being delivered because it got "lost" somewhere in transit). So if you order from Amazon (and many many people do, in spite of the delays and the cost , because they have no chpoice), the added postage fee more than cancels any discount. Often the Indian edition books are released upto a year or more after the foreign edition is released and the paper and print quality is really sucky (to make it cheap I imagine.) Give me an option of instant purchase (today you have to order books form India and wait for weeks to see how important this is) and I'd choose that in flash. Indian booksellers often take months to deliver a book not in the store inventory. Indian booksellers suck. Even an "Amazon India" would destroy them if it existed. And as for textbooks specifically only a minor subset of the good textbooks in say Mechanical Engineering is available in Indian Edition. The situation is better for "Perl in 21 days" type software books. For example Peter Norvig's "Artificial Intelligence A Modern Approach " 3d edition is slated for release at the end of 2009 in the USA. I don't expect to see it in a cheap Indian Edition till the end of 2010. I maintain that if the Kindle works well in India in terms of connectivity and so on (this remains to be seen), it will be a huge disruptive force in bookselling. Indian publishing houses are still in the 19th century as far as technology and distribution are concerned. Some of my friends were trying to set up an e-publishing startup with a kindle like device and did some market research on this. (They didn't get funding which is another story entirely).

codedivine 17y ago
Well, at my university, the common solution was to go to the library, borrow the book and then get it photocopied. Copyright infringement? Probably. Cost effective: yes. I don't know a whole lot of students in India who will spend $260 for their textbooks over their entire undergrad let alone spend $260 on a ebook reader and then spend a lot of money buying books. However, kindle may become popular with professionals perhaps.
- dagw 17y ago
  I used several photocopied books when at university. Basically someone would run off one copy of the relevant chapters, then we'd take that to a copy shop and they'd run off a dozen copies of it double sided and bind it nicely. A lot of people did it and no one ever said anything.
  - codedivine 17y ago
    Precisely. I think cost matters to students more than convenience in most cases.