4 ms·
The article failed to mention one thing -- corruption. In a chaotic, churning society, corruption is kept lower because you never know who's going to be in powe
by DanielBMarkham 19y ago
The article failed to mention one thing -- corruption. In a chaotic, churning society, corruption is kept lower because you never know who's going to be in power next year. In China you always know. That makes it too tempting for little side deals to be set up. Every one of those side deals takes a little something from the rest of their society. That's why corruption is so officially scorned in China, although it is pervasive.
I don't see them overcoming this problem with their current system, much less moving to a service economy. But I wish them well.
- robg 19y agoIt mentions it - indeed it's built around the concept. It's just not corruption in terms of paying off A or B (such as in developing or modern - if you take the extreme view - democracies. It's corruption in terms of A (an academic elite) looking out for it's own interests. I'm not qualified to judge the accuracy of the perspective. But the argument says a specific type of corruption is there and it's deeply rooted in the social fabric (even as he implies payoffs). If that's not corruption, what would you call it?
- cglee 19y agoYea, corruption is a big problem. Bribery, or gift giving, is a way of life for many Chinese people. When I was in elementary school, my mom made me bring food over every time I went to a friend's house. I'd show up ready to play Nintendo with a bowl of fried rice. It's part of the culture. It's a problem the Chinese government needs to work on. BTW, bribery is alive and well in the US too, but it's wide open (suppose to be, anyway) and it's called "lobbying" or "campaign contributions".
- DanielBMarkham 19y agoI don't know what to call it -- corruption seems to be the best word for now. For our purposes an academic elite is the same as a political party -- it holds political power. Whatever it is, the problem it presents is that there is not a single amount of predictable payments that can be made to create an economic transaction -- it's all up to the whims of the people who are involved. I guess it's possible to predict to some degree if you know all of the players, but there is no competition for doing it another way without the payments -- the same party owns the game, the tables, and all of the cards. I'm no expert either, but it seems that corruption in the states is of such a lesser degree to be of a different type altogether, at least as far as startups go. Likewise, corruption in some third world countries is so bad to make even the most trivial of enterprises fraught with hidden expenditures. Here, if I want to make a startup to, say, sell fried chicken on the street corner, I've got 2 or 3 political people to meet and make happy. Now there might be lots of crooks in the local government, but each local government can be of a different political party, as can the state and federal governments. Even in a completely crooked world, that provides incentives for each section of political power to lower corruption, at least in sections controlled by the other guy. You simply do not have that somehow-it-works setup in China. And I think it's going to be a limiting factor in their growth.
- Kaizyn 19y agoI would be willing to bet you that they have no interest in becoming a service economy. The US built its power up by having a mighty manufacturing sector - it's what let us build tanks and planes and all the other instruments of war so well in WWII. Another point to consider is that manufacturing jobs produce many more jobs to support the work than than do jobs in the service industry.
- felipe 19y ago> I would be willing to bet you that they have no interest in becoming a service economy. I completely agree with you. More so, I believe China (and other developing nations) is pursuing a knowledge economy. We were pursuing it too, until neocons like Brooks took over 7 years ago and got us stuck in the middle of the transition.
- rms 19y agoWhat is a knowledge economy, exactly? The Wikipedia article (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Knowledge_economy http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Knowledge_economy) is a whole bunch of bullshit. Knowledge economy seems contradictory to me, because information is free.
- aristus 19y agoInformation is definitely not free, my friend. In the long run, yes, the value of information is zero. Yesterday's trade secrets are tomorrow's old news. But in the short run it can be extremely valuable. Think about Seagate's QA numbers, or their profit margins, or Amazon's official opinion on FIFO warehousing, etc. All "secret" and all fairly worthless if they were leaked. But as they stand that data are vital to their businesses.
- rms 19y agoYes, that is all valuable information, but it's a long way from forming the basis of an economy.