3 ms·
I think this is a really interesting search case. What would people except Google to return? On a basic level, viewing Google as nothing more than a pure sear
by nl 12y ago
I think this is a really interesting search case.
What would people except Google to return?
On a basic level, viewing Google as nothing more than a pure search engine it seems appropriate to return results referring to the phrase "King of the United States" or close synonyms ("Emperor of the United States").
On another level, "king" could be viewed as a broad synonym for "leader". In some circumstances this works well, but in others it is extremely dangerous. I've built a toy question-answering system which uses synonyms in the broad sense. In my case "King" maps to "Leader", which maps to the DBPedia property "leader". DBPedia maps "leader"
to people with constitutional authority, which seems reasonable, but in the case of the US will return John Roberts (the chief justice).
On a truly deep level, a system could understand that the US does not have a king, and that this is a politically loaded question.
Incidentally, I think Google does a really good job with https://www.google.com/search?q=who+is+the+king+of+united+states https://www.google.com/search?q=who+is+the+king+of+united+st...
- moskie 12y agoBased on what you said, I'm not sure you're seeing what others are. Taken from JTon in this thread: http://i.imgur.com/JyVEY1p.png http://i.imgur.com/JyVEY1p.png. The problem isn't the search results shown, but a big box at the top that Google is providing as the "correct" answer to the query.
- nl 12y agoSee my response here https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8660294 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8660294
- danso 12y agoWhat's interesting is that Google seems to know what to do with other nonsensical searches. For example, "King of Canada" brings up "Queen Elizabeth II"...and so the search engine knew first to skip from the currently non-existent "King" to the next monarch (i.e. Queen), and furthermore, knew that Canada is part of the Commonwealth of Nations, which means that its queen is technically the same as the British Empire's queen. So it's kind of unclear to me how Google's search engine would seemingly jump at "Let's find a recent news item/headline" and just show it, rather than doing the "thinking" it apparently does for "King of Canada"
- vilhelm_s 12y agoSince the formatting of the "King of Canada" box and the "All Hail King Barack Obama" box are different, I guess they are produced by different pieces of software. I had only seen the second kind before, where Google shows a snippet from a webpage with some bold text to highlight why it thinks the website provides the answer to the query. But the first kind, for "King of Canada", just prints the answer. I guess they probably have some set of Wolfram Alpha-like programs to answer particular classes of queries (like artithmetic problems, or names of monarchs), an a different program to generate the snippets.
- dragonwriter 12y ago> knew that Canada is part of the Commonwealth of Nations, which means that its queen is technically the same as the British Empire's queen. (1) There is no British Empire any more, and (2) Queen Elizabeth II is Queen of Canada, but not because Canada is part of the Commonwealth of Nations. The Commonwealth of Nations is not coextensive with the set of nations that happen have the current monarch of the United Kingdom as their monarch as well (Queen Elizabeth II is also Head of the Commonwealth -- a title created because King George VI stopped being monarch -- Emporer, specifically -- of India while India remained in the Commonwealth), though there is still substantial overlap.
- michaelochurch 12y agoYou search at the King, you best not miss.
- nl 12y agoFor example, "King of Canada" brings up "Queen Elizabeth II"...and so the search engine knew first to skip from the currently non-existent "King" to the next monarch (i.e. Queen), and furthermore, knew that Canada is part of the Commonwealth of Nations, which means that its queen is technically the same as the British Empire's queen. Close, but not quite. Yes, Google is doing an equivalence of King<->Monarch But Canada actually has a Queen, separate to any historical relation with the British empire. Specifically, Freebase (owned by Google) lists Queen Elizabeth II as "Queen of Canada"[1] So it's kind of unclear to me how Google's search engine would seemingly jump at "Let's find a recent news item/headline" and just show it, rather than doing the "thinking" it apparently does for "King of Canada" Yeah, Google didn't do a good job for "King of the USA" in this case. Generally I believe it tries to surface recent headlines for a search, and this is what was being seen here. Unfortunately the UI for that is similar to the "fact" UI, and that has created some confusion here. [1] https://www.freebase.com/m/0d060g?any=%2Fcommon%2Ftopic#/government/governmental_jurisdiction https://www.freebase.com/m/0d060g?any=%2Fcommon%2Ftopic#/gov...