3 ms·
You're right. Most kids would probably know jack squat if it were up to them. I think I was just thinking a little too much about myself because I felt jailed i
by chrischen 17y ago
You're right. Most kids would probably know jack squat if it were up to them. I think I was just thinking a little too much about myself because I felt jailed in by education.
But on the other hand even though we force those kids to learn algebra who might not have learned it if it was up to them, how much do they really understand of it when they are initially taught? Do they only truly learn it when they rediscover it later on in life (perhaps at a more natural moment when it becomes practical) only to have the educational system take credit?
I mean even in college some of my friends take the attitude of pass now and learn the stuff for real when they get their jobs later in life.
I'm thinking we could improve efficiency by somehow bypassing the pass now stage. Of course it's much more complicated to do that than it seems.
Instead of focusing on cramming info to give the illusion of education, we could teach children why they should learn, and try to get them interested and self motivated.
- johnnybgoode 17y agoYou are on the right track, chrischen. Many of us seem to have made the hidden assumption that we are first supposed to have a two-decade-long "education" phase, and only then a "real world" phase. I'll bet even the not-so-bright kids can tell that the tasks they're ordered to complete while in the child processing system[1] are artificial, arbitrary, inefficient, and often useless. Quite a few people have admitted that bright kids would probably be better off outside the system, but I believe this applies even to the less intelligent kids. You're more likely to encourage yourself to learn if you enjoy what you're learning and/or you see that it really matters in some way; i.e., it has some real-world effect beyond some grade on a test. Things work out better in many, many ways when people of all levels of intelligence are allowed to learn and work as they wish. [1] Credit for this term goes to HN poster gruseom; I believe he coined it.