3 ms·
The key pages of the full report relevant to the US providers believed to include Facebook are 127-133. Some of the statements it makes are much more modest th
by notahacker 12y ago
The key pages of the full report relevant to the US providers believed to include Facebook are 127-133.
Some of the statements it makes are much more modest than the politicised responses; others a fair bit more dubious.... either way I think the below are more interesting talking points than the original article...
(i) They believe multiple accounts were closed by the service providers themselves due to "terrorist content", so they believe the service providers are failing in an assumed duty to share information with UK intelligence services more than an assumed duty to scan the content.
(ii) Some [likely US] providers did share details directly with UK intelligence after the fact whilst others were achieved indirectly via a [presumably US] "partner agency".
(iii) The "partner agency" didn't share everything that was possible to share either, which [unlike the computer service providers] GCHQ apparently considers normal and acceptable given their "resource constraints".
(iv) The report claim that Adebowale "obviously" had a "number of accounts" with the service provider the media are claiming to be Facebook, some of which were closed down "because they hit triggers which we believe were related to their criteria for closing things down on the basis of terrorist content". Which suggests either the provider in question wasn't Facebook, or that the report authors have a serious lack of understanding either of what a Facebook account is or what Facebook's policy on an individual having several accounts is.
(v) GCHQ suggests that an account with the text "let's kill a soldier" should have triggered algorithms detecting potential terrorist content, which implies they believe that [allegedly] Facebook could or should have algorithms that can parse sentences containing trigger words that happen to be extremely common, rather than simple blacklists and flagging functionality.