3 ms·
This report just seems like a whitewash to try to blame an Internet company with no legal and (arguably) no ethical duty to monitor communications over its netw
by Silhouette 12y ago
This report just seems like a whitewash to try to blame an Internet company with no legal and (arguably) no ethical duty to monitor communications over its network for the collective repeated failings of the security services.
According to various reports in the serious media today, the security services had these two in their sights seven times before the attack. Some commenters also seem to be suggesting that surveillance was undermined, possibly as late as the day before the attack, by numerous procedural errors by those security services, though I haven't yet seen a specific citation of anywhere the ISC report itself states this.
In any case, why do we still pretend that it is plausible to monitor everything said on-line, correctly identify every genuine threat needle in the hyperbole haystack, and anticipate and prevent every small-scale, isolated violent attack by bad people?
While I would never make light of the loss to Lee Rigby and his family and friends, objectively this appears to have been an isolated incident with a single victim, given coverage out of all proportion by the media because someone said "terrorism". There were hundreds of murders in the UK last year, and I doubt the others were any less tragic for those affected, but we don't see David Cameron, Theresa May and Malcolm Rifkind calling for draconian state surveillance powers to avoid repeats of all the other killings.
- yimbosmeen 12y agoYou hold a very minority opinion. Personally I don't see a problem with this kind of monitoring, AND I would go further... - There are many many young people on facebook. Every year a percentage of these innocents decide to kill themselves. I think facebook have a MORAL OBLIGATION to monitor all language used in facebook posts in order to ascertain potential suicide threats - which should then be reported to the appropriate authorities. - Every year thousands of people die of hear attacks brought about by years of unhealthy living. It is facebooks MORAL RESPONSIBILITY to monitor the word density of posts, giving extra weight to words like 'pie', 'cake' and 'spachumnauzer' - These perpetrators should be reported to the relevant NHS department for immediate medically induced coma therapy[1] - EVERY, SINGLE, YEAR, millions of illegal immigrants done come over to our country illegally, in order to steal our benefits. Facebooks continued lack of action in monitoring facebook photos for suspicious foreign looking persons in a job type role consists of MORAL CONSTIPATION on the part of Facebook. All foreign-ish photos should be vetted by the appropriate vets. [1] study after study show people in comas are at a significantly lessenered risk of dying of heart attacks - I don't have the links right now, but believe me, they do!
- regularfry 12y agoToo subtle, sir. Too subtle.