4 ms·
This is a very unfortunate story, and it's also very unfortunate that the author hasn't been helped by medical science. The author's subjective suffering should
by throwaway67851 12y ago
This is a very unfortunate story, and it's also very unfortunate that the author hasn't been helped by medical science. The author's subjective suffering should not be up for debate. Idiopathic pain and fatigue disorders are impossibly frustrating to diagnose and treat, and have a tremendous negative impact in a person's quality of life.
That said, this post has many hallmarks of pseudoscience, and I'm afraid that the author may be invested in pseudo-scientific diagnoses to his own detriment.
For example, he is very specific about the genetic origins of his disorder and even enumerates three very specific downstream effects of his genetic polymorphisms (low catecholamine levels, 'toxin' retention, and high elimination rates of various minerals). However, any genetic disorders that are well-understood enough to detect and enumerate like this would absolutely have a name and associated diagnosis.
Furthermore, the specific factors he lists (low serotonin and dopamine, high toxin retention, high mineral elimination) map more closely to pseudoscientific principles than they do to actually medical conditions. For example, his claim that his body specifically stores 'toxins' such as benzene and mercury while 'normal' people's bodies eliminate the same toxins is a classic pseudoscientific explanation that has no basis in reality.
Again, I'm not suggesting that he isn't suffering or that his symptoms aren't actually happening. But the amount of pseudoscience in this post makes me concerned that he is moving in the wrong direction or even entering a cycle of worsening his own symptoms with his pre-occupation with pseudoscientific diagnoses and insistence that mainstream medicine can't understand his symptoms.
This is a surprisingly common scenario, common enough that it has its own diagnosis: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Somatic_symptom_disorder http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Somatic_symptom_disorder The greatest hurdle in treating a somatic symptom disorder is convincing the patient that mental health treatment will be beneficial to their symptoms, which are largely physical. As a consequence, many sufferers turn to alternative medicine which provides comforting but largely false physical explanations for their symptoms involving disorders such as high toxin levels, low mineral levels, and low serotonin and dopamine levels, which is precisely what the author insists is causing his symptoms.
- JacksonGariety 12y agoPseudoscience is not necessarily bad. Most of psychology and philosophy, for instance, is essentially pseudoscience.
- meowface 12y agoIt's certainly bad when it's concerning physical medicine.
- JacksonGariety 12y agoWhat we consider "science" appeared in the 1600's with Galileo/Descartes. People most certainly made progress in medicine prior to that time.
- bishnu 12y agoI would disagree with this assessment. If X is not a science, it does not follow that X is a pseudoscience.
- JacksonGariety 12y agoPseudoscience is an un-scientific practice which people _generally assume_ to be scientific. Psychology most certainly applies, and I think the author's conclusions are the best he's got at the moment because science cannot help him.
- thedufer 12y agoCan you share your definition of pseudoscience? You are clearly using quite a different one from the rest of the commenters here. Under the usual definitions, philosophy is neither science nor pseudoscience, and psychology is firmly in the realm of science.
- JacksonGariety 12y agoPseudoscience is a non-scientific practice which people ~generally assume~ to be scientific. There are many areas of philosophy which people believe are done via science. I'd say metaphysics is a pseudoscience because people assume it's akin to physics. Most modern psychology (not all of it, and not psychiatry) is based on Freud and Lacan's psychoanalytic practice. This practice people generally assume to be scientific because their health insurance covers it, but it has no scientific basis. I'd also say some people assume political theory to be scientific, as many mistake it for economics and sociology which ~are~ scientific. Political theory is not. EDIT: Aesthetics and philosophy of mind are other areas which people mistakenly think involve neurobiology, but they don't.
- westoncb 12y agoI've got to second that it's probably worthwhile for the author to check out and consider the wikipedia article. I pretty much gave up programming for six years, utterly convinced that I had a physical disorder causing me constant pain in wrists, hands, elbows, shoulders, etc. I tried all kinds of physical approaches during that time, many of which would appear to impact it in one way or another, but none that really helped (instead it was that my worrying more or less impacted my essentially mental disorder that manifested somatically). A key aspect to it is that there is no distinguishing the symptoms from actual physical sensations. I could have started making progress with my own issues years earlier when someone brought up this possibility to me, except that I felt like what I was experiencing was 'too real' to be mental, or something. Medical practitioners outside of mental health seem relatively unaware of these disorders, but if you speak with a psychiatrist, you may receive some useful info. It's worth a shot. Here are a couple sources for further reading: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Conversion_disorder http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Conversion_disorder This is a good book on going about recovery. You'll have to forgive the title; the reason it's there is the physical site for these disorders tends to follow trends in society, and at the time of writing back and neck pain were the most common occurrences (it's consistent with the theory behind these disorders that such trends would exist), AND a very large proportion of chronic back/neck pain turn out to be psychosomatic. http://www.amazon.com/Rapid-Recovery-Back-Neck-Pain-ebook/dp/B0056VBF4I/ http://www.amazon.com/Rapid-Recovery-Back-Neck-Pain-ebook/dp... It's also interesting to see the page for the Seattle Repetitive Injury Support Team, which (after a majority of their members solved their problems) now feels convinced that the most troublesome, persistent repetitive strain injuries are psychosomatic. http://www.satori.org/rist/ http://www.satori.org/rist/ You can also see the extents that I went to to avoid physical activation of my symptoms, here: http://tiledtext.com http://tiledtext.com That's how convinced I was that they were physical, though now I have no doubt about their mental origin—and I can use computers almost completely freely now :D
- appleflaxen 12y agoHoly cow. It's brave of you to share your personal experience with this. It's great that you are feeling better, and awesome that you are willing to use your mistakes to help someone else.
- _Robbie 12y agoI am skeptical that his explanations are completely pseudo-scientific and have no basis is fact. If these explanations sound unscientific, I think it is more likely that it from the author simplifying the explanation of his problem, and perhaps he is confused about or is miss-communicating what his doctors have told him. One person, who I was living with to shorten my commute to the hospital, which I was visiting three days a week for treatment ... Getting treatment at a hospital implies that doctors identified some known medical condition they could treat. My body retains toxins—and not, like, generic “toxins” that health nuts talk about, I mean real toxins, like benzene and mercury. If there are tests for benzene and mercury, this could indicate a medically detectable problem. He also seems to dismiss the pseudo-scientific explanation of toxins. My body rejects things it should keep, like magnesium. Especially magnesium. Also zinc. Again, if there are tests for this, there might be some truth to this. It is unclear how much of his description of his medical problems is known for certain, or how much of this is speculation. He admits that he "barely understand"s it. I would like to hear a medical explanation for why his explanation is impossible or problematic before concluding that it is simply pseudo-scientific gobbledygook.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- overhere 12y agoAs someone who also suffers chronic health issues with no full relief (yet) from the mainstream/alternative/mental health fields, I would like to just toss out this out for the original poster. You should really look deeply into your diet and do a lot of research. This site: http://selfhacked.com/ http://selfhacked.com/ is the first I've come across that has begun to enable progress for me. For example, I found out about longvida curcumin from it, and it's been the single most helpful thing I've ever taken (pharmaceutical or natural) to help with my inflammation issues. Everyone is different; some people's issues may be psychosomatic (for me, my issues begin in the GI tract and cause issues throughout my body), but as someone who's run through the system, it really illuminates just how little modern medicine really knows about the body.
- eva89 12y agoearn at your home and get paid $5708 in 1 month by working on the internet If You do not have time to Come to Meet then You can Visit our Website Where You can Get Complete Training About this Online Money Making Program register here...swipebuckdotkom
- tripzilch 12y ago(disclaimer: I don't know if this corresponds to what the author has been doing, it's based on my own personal experience and by now ~15y struggles with something similar--thankfully minus the pain he describes) The thing is, if you've had nine years of battling these symptoms (that are mysterious and won't go away), you've had time to have go at all of the approaches you name. Try them one by one, in combination, note what seems to work, psychological/mental, physiological, dietary, environmental, natural, pseudo-scientific, alternative, magical, religious, (quasi) pseudo-religious ... you name it. You become an expert at yourself, but that's super hard because you are most biased at this topic (step one: keep a diary). Obviously there will also be placebo effects (which I hope we all agree do have tangible medical effects), and sometimes the pseudoscientific-treatment-that-doesn't-work will have better placebo effects than the medical/scientific-treatment-that-doesn't-work. Either way, as long as you keep moving, keep fighting, and keep a clear head about it, you'll keep learning, even from the things that are on the surface bullshit (and sometimes you just need a break and try something that couldn't possibly work). I too hope that indeed this person is not stuck in a cycle of pre-occupation with one particular thing, but he is just describing his most current working-theory in the continuous string of attempts.