3 ms·
it's (sadly) very refreshing honesty from a scientist. In grad school, I counseled a junior grad student on this sort of phenomenon, she didn't take my advice
by dnautics 12y ago
it's (sadly) very refreshing honesty from a scientist. In grad school, I counseled a junior grad student on this sort of phenomenon, she didn't take my advice and learned a very hard lesson - spending 4 years of grad school chasing down ghosts. On the other hand, it wasn't a waste, she got a very good job in the pharma industry on the back of her commitment to sussing out errors, her honesty and introspection.
- tormeh 12y agoGiven the potential upsides, I would say it's worth finding the errors in this reactionless drive. Even if it turns out to be just a fantasy the poorly understood effects that need to be "just so" might be interesting in their own right.
- jessriedel 12y agoThat seems like a compelling position until you're exposed to a million such cases. There's no end to the number of weird, malfunctioning pieces of equipment or complicated many-body systems for which we have a theory that sort of explains them with a few poorly understood wrinkles.
- saalweachter 12y agoYes, yes, a million times yes. In a world as big as ours, it's reasonable to diversify your investments and keep a few million to one long-shots going, but it's important not to lose sight of the odds. Buy a lotto ticket every now and again, but put the bulk of your money in a 401k or other solid investment. In this case, I think we're giving this idea more or less exactly the right amount of attention: one dedicated crank (and I use that term lovingly) devoting his life to his crazy theory, and a handful of less invested others occasionally checking in on it. If he can make it work, fantastic, if he can't, well, we didn't waste too much on it.