6 ms·
A really amazing, honest, and straightforward account from the grad student in the lab. http://www.otherhand.org/home-page/physics/graduate-studies-in-physics-
by dnautics 12y ago
A really amazing, honest, and straightforward account from the grad student in the lab.
http://www.otherhand.org/home-page/physics/graduate-studies-in-physics-at-cal-state-university-fullerton/ http://www.otherhand.org/home-page/physics/graduate-studies-...
- ajuc 12y ago"Your access to this site has been limited" Http 503.
- cygx 12y agoSome quotes from the end of the article: As time progressed and the experimental apparatus more refined, the “effect” seemed to get smaller, and that’s a REAL bad sign. It was already well below what the theory predicted. That sets off alarm bells. After all this time, if something isn’t in hand to float around a table top, its should still at least be producing unequivocal results. I am aware of only one positive replication attempt, and even that experimenter (Paul March) had concerns over its validity. All other replication attempts have either been negative or ambiguous. My own experiments were ambiguous. It seems to make the effect happen, a lot of parameters for the test devices, some not clearly understood, need to be “just so”. The question remains, are the devices being dialed in to create a real effect, or do things need to be just so to cause merely a false positive?
- dnautics 12y agoit's (sadly) very refreshing honesty from a scientist. In grad school, I counseled a junior grad student on this sort of phenomenon, she didn't take my advice and learned a very hard lesson - spending 4 years of grad school chasing down ghosts. On the other hand, it wasn't a waste, she got a very good job in the pharma industry on the back of her commitment to sussing out errors, her honesty and introspection.
- tormeh 12y agoGiven the potential upsides, I would say it's worth finding the errors in this reactionless drive. Even if it turns out to be just a fantasy the poorly understood effects that need to be "just so" might be interesting in their own right.
- jessriedel 12y agoThat seems like a compelling position until you're exposed to a million such cases. There's no end to the number of weird, malfunctioning pieces of equipment or complicated many-body systems for which we have a theory that sort of explains them with a few poorly understood wrinkles.
- saalweachter 12y agoYes, yes, a million times yes. In a world as big as ours, it's reasonable to diversify your investments and keep a few million to one long-shots going, but it's important not to lose sight of the odds. Buy a lotto ticket every now and again, but put the bulk of your money in a 401k or other solid investment. In this case, I think we're giving this idea more or less exactly the right amount of attention: one dedicated crank (and I use that term lovingly) devoting his life to his crazy theory, and a handful of less invested others occasionally checking in on it. If he can make it work, fantastic, if he can't, well, we didn't waste too much on it.
- nl 12y agoThis is fantastic. I love this little anecdote: I found Hamilton to be extremely bright and knowledgeable, although sometimes I wondered if there was more to him than it appeared. I knew he gave regular briefing sessions at the Pentagon, which seemed strange for an electric car guy. But there was also a time we were speaking on the phone about the possibilities of wormholes and the like. He asked me if I thought it would be possible to create a wormhole with one end being on the surface of the Sun and the other over an enemy on the battle field. I think I was stunned into silence for quite some time, but eventually regained enough composure to say while I had not thought about that before (an understatement!), I supposed it was theoretically possible. Off topic rant: Crazy conspiracy people have no idea about how this kind of stuff happens all the time. 99.99% of things never go anywhere, but 0.01% turn into DARPA projects, and 0.01% of those actually turn into better saucepans, and 0.01% of those turn into actual weapons.
- morcheeba 12y agoLet's hope the sun-wormhole opens above that saucepan ... perfect for backpacking!