3 ms·
That's a bit inaccurate. Prosecutors have legal discretion on a case-by-case basis, but a President not enforcing large sections of the law has never been test
by protomyth 12y ago
That's a bit inaccurate. Prosecutors have legal discretion on a case-by-case basis, but a President not enforcing large sections of the law has never been tested. This is going to be complicated and messy. If your belief is the truth, what happens when the next President decides not to enforce the laws they don't like?
- anigbrowl 12y agoNot so. The delegation of discretionary power to the agency (whose head serves at the pleasure of the President) is explicit in the statute. As I pointed out above, the President is not declining to enforce the law, but promulgating standards for how that discretion should be applied. Furthermore, this is not as novel a situation as some commentators claim, because such standards are regularly promulgated in other similar contexts, such as rules not to automatically exclude would-be immigrants who infected with HIV (instituted and terminated by executive fiat) or to grant refugee status to people from conflict/disaster zones, which are similar exercises of discretion. The only 'large' thing here is the number of people who might qualify for residential status under the newly-promulgated criteria for evaluation (eg 5 year continuous presence inside the US plus parental relationship to a US citizen/LPR plus absence of felony convictions). Here again is the DoJ's legal memorandum on the allowable scope of executive action in this context - you'll notice that it affirms the President's powers to act in some respects while denying it in others. I'd be glad to discuss it in depth but the document is necessarily long and technical. http://www.justice.gov/sites/default/files/olc/opinions/attachments/2014/11/20/2014-11-19-auth-prioritize-removal.pdf http://www.justice.gov/sites/default/files/olc/opinions/atta...
- protomyth 12y agoI've read the finding by the President's appointed people and do not find their argument compelling as many didn't when President Bush's appointees delivered a similar finding on the use of waterboarding.
- anigbrowl 12y agoThat's a bullshit argument and you know it. If you have actually read it why don't you point out what part of their argument you consider to be flawed? You started out making a legal claim (that Obama had decided not to enforce parts of the law, and that there was no legislative backing for this decision). Now you're making rhetorical arguments, ie suggesting that appointees will serve up whatever argument the President wants - despite the fact the opinion includes a denial of presidential authority on one issue that was inquired about, and despite my (very briefly) pointing out the legislative basis of executive authority and non-controversial examples of its use on a collective rather than an individual basis. I'm not expecting a legal brief but you haven't offered anything substantive at all. (Edit for formatting)
- protomyth 12y agoIts not a bs argument, as even the document you cited includes: "The Department of Homeland Security’s proposed deferred action program for parents of recipients of deferred action under the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals program would not be a permissible exercise of DHS’s enforcement discretion." Presidents who try to weasel around the law, particularly when they spent the earlier part of the year telling us it wouldn't be right are out of line.
- anigbrowl 12y agoI already alluded twice to the fact that the document affirms the legality of some proposed action and denies that of others - so it seems you finally took a look at it and found the denial that I already told you about. And guess what, the executive action announced last week does not include the proposal which this memo said would be outside the scope of Presidential authority. Presidents who try to weasel around the law, particularly when they spent the earlier part of the year telling us it wouldn't be right are out of line. Except that that hasn't happened here; as far as I can tell changes announced by the President last week are entirely consistent with the law. Let's have another look at the memo, with the sentence you quoted in its context: (^^ edited to fix a a word mistake - I said proposed instead of announced) The Department of Homeland Security’s proposed policy to prioritize the removal of certain aliens unlawfully present in the United States would be a permissible exercise of DHS’s discretion to enforce the immigration laws. The Department of Homeland Security’s proposed deferred action program for parents of U.S. citizens and legal permanent residents would also be a permissible exercise of DHS’s discretion to enforce the immigration laws. The Department of Homeland Security’s proposed deferred action program for parents of recipients of deferred action under the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals program would not be a permissible exercise of DHS’s enforcement discretion. (From http://www.justice.gov/sites/default/files/olc/opinions/attachments/2014/11/20/2014-11-19-auth-prioritize-removal.pdf; http://www.justice.gov/sites/default/files/olc/opinions/atta... emphasis added by me) So the memo says that 2 proposed changes would be permissible, and one would not. You chose to quote only the last one, and make it look like Obama is riding roughshod over the law - except that his policy as announced only implemented the first two proposals. He said that only parents of US citizen or Legal Permanent Resident children would be able to apply for deferred action - there was no such provision for parents of children who received deferred action (often referred to in the media as 'DREAMers'), and Obama actually received some criticism from immigration activists over that. You know, if you had simply said you think Obama's action is terrible policy I'd have no problem with that - I wouldn't agree, but it's a totally valid opinion. But instead you went for making claims that the President was acting outside the law, which are simply not supported by the facts, and now you've ended up pulling things out of context in an attempt to shore up your erroneous position, but which in fact undermine it further. So yes, I still say your argument is bullshit.
- pastProlog 12y ago> That's a bit inaccurate. Prosecutors have legal discretion on a case-by-case basis, but a President not enforcing large sections of the law has never been tested...what happens when the next President decides not to enforce the laws they don't like? That's a bit inaccurate as well. Reagan and his administration were fairly open that they were not going to enforce sections of law as well, and in the same area, labor law. Particularly with directives sent to the Department of Labor's Occupational Safety and Health Administration. http://www.nytimes.com/1984/06/09/opinion/looking-for-loopholes-at-osha.html http://www.nytimes.com/1984/06/09/opinion/looking-for-loopho... The idea that Reagan was enforcing OSHA labor laws, but that Obama is not enforcing immigration labor laws, is a bit hard to swallow.
- protomyth 12y agoJust because Reagan did it does not make it right. The executive is supposed to execute the law, not pick and chose what laws to follow. If a President doesn't like the law then lobby for new one. If the voters don't give you the votes then you suck it up and execute as written.