3 ms·
(responding both to you and 'duckingtest') No, the 'answer' is not that the person you disagree with "believes in magic" or "doesn't understand" the field they
by nkurz 12y ago
(responding both to you and 'duckingtest')
No, the 'answer' is not that the person you disagree with "believes in magic" or "doesn't understand" the field they work in as respected experts. Appell goes on to try to explain why climate modelling is concerned with 'projection' rather than 'prediction', and has a very clear view of the difference between science and magic.
Briggs has been a professor of statistics at Cornell, written several book on statistics, and published dozens of peer reviewed papers. Claiming that he is the "statistical equivalent of an anti-vaccer" might be a useful rhetorical strategy but unless you can point to some prominent mainstream career vaccine researchers that you'd also lump into this category, it has no basis in truth.
Playing to a home crowd is easy, but has left us where we are with two locked down groups each trying to persuade the undecided middle that their opponent is the devil incarnate. This doesn't lead anywhere desirable, just to further entrenchment of positions. The "way out" is trying to formulate criticism that can be understood by the party being criticized and influences them and their followers to reevaluate their beliefs and approaches.
I think it has to be something stylistic that we as readers associate with a world-view (a dog whistle) rather than the actual content of the statements. Take the paragraph in "Lesson 1":
If you say the mixed marriage of splicing the disjoint
series does not matter, you are making a judgment. Is it
true? How can you prove it? It doesn’t seem true on its
face. Significance tests are circular arguments here. After
the marriage, you are left with unquantifiable uncertainty.
I'd assert that this paragraph can only appear on the 'denier' side of things. Is this because it embraces uncertainty, and implies we should not act until we have properly quantified it? One of the most interesting exchanges in the comments is between 'Sheri' and 'Brandon Gates', on whether it's better to accept a known-flawed model or to throw it out and have no model at all.
My request to 'signalsmith', concentrating on Briggs because his positions are more self-contained: Re-reread Briggs article, ignoring the set-up paragraphs that explain what he's criticizing and why. That is, blind yourself as best as you can to the side that he is taking. Stop at the point where your pulse starts to rise and report back. Then let's see how 'duckingtest' responds to the same passage.