2 ms·
We were talking about the revenues - the idea was that all tax revenue ultimately comes "from people", every economic decision affects people - because people a
by smsm42 12y ago
We were talking about the revenues - the idea was that all tax revenue ultimately comes "from people", every economic decision affects people - because people are the only willful agents in the economy, there's nobody else.
>>> The only thing taxes change is who gets to control where the money goes.
Not entirely. The government usually proves to have quite inefficient with how it spends revenues. Sometimes it is necessary - i.e., feeding the destitute produces no money, but has a humanitarian value. Sometimes, it is not - like spending billions on bridges to nowhere and crony projects that collapse the minute government financing is withdrawn. So we also have to consider the destruction of value that the government involvement usually brings about. Of course, corporations can destroy value too - but usually can't survive for very long once they started to do it unless they manage to stop. For the government, it has to be extraordinarily destructive to collapse, for a company, the bar is much lower.
>>> your assertions about profit going to hiring, supplies, and services are clearly false. It happens, but it's certainly not a given.
Err, I'm not sure where your "clearly false" comes from. Is it clear to you that corporations do not spend money on hiring, supplies and services? How they then manage to have people show up to work and suppliers to give them supplies and services, if they don't pay for it? Also, if some fairyland corporation ever managed to pull off such impossible trick, it still wouldn't change a thing, as that would only mean entire revenue goes to the corporation owners - i.e., again, "people".