3 ms·
> Are there situations when we can legally expect a company to fight for our privacy I think it depends on the definition of "papers, and effects" in 4A (I'm n
by pc86 12y ago
> Are there situations when we can legally expect a company to fight for our privacy
I think it depends on the definition of "papers, and effects" in 4A (I'm not an attorney so I really don't know the specifics). One could certainly make the argument that under certain circumstances you can disclose information to certain parties while maintaining a reasonable expectation of privacy. I would imagine this is the basis of doctor-patient and attorney-client confidentiality but that's just assumption on my part.
- rayiner 12y agoEvidentiary privileges and the 4th amendment interact, but aren't directly related. Obviously doctors and lawyers have a 4th amendment expectation of privacy over their own documents, but you don't have one over their documents. Moreover, they can be compelled to turn over copies of documents they have related to you. That's one of the issues that gets lost in the shuffle: the 4th amendment was written against the backdrop of the almost unlimited power of the common law subpoena. When the government demands a service provider turn over someone's electronic records, that doesn't fall within the 4th amendment (it's not a search), nor does it fall within the 5th (it's not self-incrimination).