4 ms·
Maybe if Google actually open-sourced as much software as they consume, that would offer a way out. Some people would still want to run the centralized as-a-se
by notacoward 12y ago
Maybe if Google actually open-sourced as much software as they consume, that would offer a way out. Some people would still want to run the centralized as-a-service tools because it's on a huge professionally-run infrastructure and because of network effects. Others might want to run the same services locally, to support privacy/decentralization goals like the OP's. Google's main revenue stream (ads) shouldn't be affected, and they'd even benefit from outside contributions.
So why don't they do this? Because of the difference between "shouldn't" and "wouldn't" at the end of the last paragraph. What if code to support ads - or other invasions of privacy - were embedded into every other thing they might open source? Then the sheer difficulty of refactoring to "sanitize" everything else would probably create a sufficient barrier to opening it up, and revealing how all of that ad infrastructure really works might hurt their business in other ways.
When Google continues to run as the new AOL (closed source, walled garden) I don't think it's part of a deliberate philosophy. Nor is it an accident. It's because their continued uber-prosperity, if not their actual survival, depends on it.
- kragen 12y agoI don't think it has to be that extreme. They do have a corporate culture of extreme secrecy, which I think comes from growing up in the shadow of Microsoft, Yahoo, and other much bigger companies. But I don't think their survival or even prosperity depends on secrecy any more. However, it's deeply embedded in their corporate culture, and I think it's actually spreading to other Silicon Valley companies. There is an issue of incentives, but I don't think it's as strong as you think. I think it's just that running services makes them money, while releasing open-source software doesn't, so they devote lots of effort to running services, and comparatively little to releasing open-source software. It would be very challenging for them to open-source "as much software as they consume." That would be a many-billions-of-dollars effort. But it wouldn't be necessary — the great thing about software is that you can copy it, so even if you only release a tiny fraction of the amount of software as you "consume", everyone still benefits.