9 ms·
Eschewing Zshell for Emacs
- mronge 12y agoI've tried living in eshell but zsch auto complete is just too damn good. Is there really good auto completion for eshell?
- wging 12y agoI seem to be getting some good completions for files just from Company-mode. I typed "/us" and got a list including /usr/, /usr/bin, /usr/lib, etc. Also, tab-completion seems somewhat good. I typed /u and TABbed, and got /usr/. /usr/bin/lv gives me /usr/bin/leave on first TAB, then cycles through /usr/bin/llvm-g++, etc. on subsequent tabs. Globbing: ls /*.js did what you'd want within a directory whose subdirectories contain a lot of .js files. It looks like someone added completions for git (and bzr, hg, if you care): http://tsdh.wordpress.com/2013/05/31/eshell-completion-for-git-bzr-and-hg/ http://tsdh.wordpress.com/2013/05/31/eshell-completion-for-g... Works pretty well. I wonder if there's a way to provide a bridge with zsh's completions, such that if you have completions for zsh, you have them for eshell.
- wyclif 12y agoI have all kinds of extended globbing turned on in my ~/.zshrc like so: #Superglobs setopt extendedglob unsetopt caseglob I haven't used eshell, and I see no need to with zsh. This lets me glob 'ls */.txt', etc.
- dllthomas 12y agoI wonder how easy it would be to construct the necessary zsh context, to just extract the completion from zsh...
- technomancy 12y agoI've found it quite good, but more compelling is that when you want to add new completions you can use lisp instead of some crazy one off half language.
- gcv 12y agoEshell works, but it does not use term.el, and so has terminal compatibility problems with many utilities (the progress indication of curl or homebrew, for example). I have found it much more practical to stick with zsh, but use ansi-term or multi-term to launch the shell from inside Emacs windows. Performance in situations when the terminal wants to spit out a lot of output leaves much to be desired, but the convenience of staying inside Emacs outweighs the drawbacks.
- michaelsbradley 12y agoAnother option is to run Emacs as a daemon, and then "live inside" tmux while moving between terminal-mode emacsclient , zsh/bash, etc. running in tmux sessions, windows and panes. My personal workflow moved that direction about a year ago and I've never looked back.
- GeoffWozniak 12y agoI have tried. And I can't. It's just too slow when working with tons of output (which is common in my work). (term-mode is no better.) Emacs is one of my favourite tools on a computer. I love Lisp (even Elisp, which is getting closer to Common Lisp as time goes on) and I love the interaction, but Emacs is not good for serious terminal/shell work and it, sadly, is pretty annoying as a tiling "window" manager. Maybe with multi-threading it will get better, but until then, I can't see a compelling reason to work exclusively in Eshell.
- gnuvince 12y agoI use ansi-term for quick tasks (e.g. re-run a build command), but you are absolutely right, if there's going to be a lot of output, I'm using my old trusty urxvt,
- dfan 12y agoYeah, I am a big fan of eshell in general but too much of the time I want to do a lot of I/O, at which it is dog slow.
- hollerith 12y ago>Emacs is not good for serious terminal/shell work I am interested in this aspect of Emacs (since there're very few things traditionally done by Emacs that Emacs is too slow at), but confused by your comment. My first guess was that the tons of output take longer to get inserted into an Emacs buffer than they take to get inserted into the buffer of a good terminal-emulation application. But surely you realize that multi-threading wouldn't help with that, hence my confusion. Can you give an example of a program that produces too much output for Emacs to keep up with? Does the program generating the tons of output do a lot of cursor addressing (like, e.g., the progress bar of homebrew or curl does)? Have you tried shell mode as well as eshell mode?
- warfangle 12y agoI've run into similar issues. It seems to be the draw speed that is very slow. Each 80char line takes a good 10ms to render, which when working with a fast command that outputs a lot of text... The command will have been done for thirty seconds while eshell is still sputtering along showing output. This is especially noticible with my on-modified-run-tests script - if there is a long stack trace, often times it's faster to kill the task and start it again rather than letting it finish.
- spain 12y agoOne thing I really like about Eshell is how you can make the whole buffer editable. Printed too many lines by accident? Just mark the whole region and do M-x delete-non-matching lines. Other fun things to do include using output redirection to insert text straight into buffers! One last cool thing is that Eshell comes with it's own little pseudo-devices like /dev/kill and /dev/clip, you can probably guess what they're for. Although as awesome as it is, there are still some places where I have no choice but to use a real terminal. This is mostly curses-like interfaces and stuff. I find it funny that the author omitted one of the biggest missing features in Eshell: input redirection, you just can't do it. Here's further reading for anyone interested in Eshell, I think this is the most comprehensive little guide out there: http://www.masteringemacs.org/article/complete-guide-mastering-eshell http://www.masteringemacs.org/article/complete-guide-masteri...
- dllthomas 12y ago"This is mostly curses-like interfaces and stuff." Which is, of course, a great example of the reason we need to provide as much functionality as we reasonably can outside such interfaces (including GUI interfaces).
- username223 12y agoI have tried to like it, but the lack of input redirection is just pathetic. Worse, rather than just calling a real shell when it detects attempted input redirection, it chastises you and refuses to do anything. Plus, while Emacs' "M-x command" completion is great, Eshell was still about as good as mid-90s Bash the last time I tried it. And then there's the cost of learning yet another slightly-different shell syntax. While this could probably be done right, it hasn't been in the 10+ years of Eshell's existence, so I'm not holding my breath.
- smenko 12y agoOh, please! Not another one!.....