3 ms·
HN itself is perfectly readable without cookies or Javascript. Even if you want to login, vote, comment, and post, all of that can be done without Javascript (
by pmoriarty 12y ago
HN itself is perfectly readable without cookies or Javascript.
Even if you want to login, vote, comment, and post, all of that can be done without Javascript (though you do need to at least temporarily enable cookies).
I am really grateful to HN for making this design choice. Javascript is superflous for 99.9% of websites. It's an unfortunate design choice to use it anyway.
I wish I could say that I hope website creators would move away from Javascript and other "dynamic" (ie. turing-complete, overpowered) technologies. But it's clear that's not going to happen.
In light of that, privacy and security tools will have to adapt and somehow find a way to protect their user's privacy and security despite having Javascript enabled.
Right now, the best hope I see for something like that is having light-weight disposable VMs/jails/containers and sandboxes. At least that could limit the damage that Javascript does to a single tab or session.
- abroncs 12y ago> Javascript is superflous for 99.9% of websites. For web sites, yes. For web applications though (of which there are more every day), it's definitely not.
- smt88 12y ago"Superfluous" is not the same as "not necessary in practice" in this case. There are many websites that use JavaScript for polyfills, browser detection, screen detection, and scroll detection. In some cases there are alternatives, but that doesn't mean those alternatives are ubiquitous.
- nbrogi 12y agoAre you guys kidding!? JavaScript is not useless at all. None of you use Gmail..? Any other web app of any kind? Facebook..? I read their page and honestly I don't see who would want to be unable to use 90% of the web to have privacy.