3 ms·
I should have been more specific because I don't think what I was trying to communicate came across. I did not mean to imply that these people are not experts a
by bduerst 12y ago
I should have been more specific because I don't think what I was trying to communicate came across. I did not mean to imply that these people are not experts at anything, just that they should publish findings, test results, or at least a white paper on proof of concept.
As it is, this website reads like they did the napkin math for the idea and are using only their credentials to legitimize it. Its an appeal to authority.
- jmadsen 12y agoThose are valid points, but I think too many here are assuming they don't have anything more substantial & this website is their entire speil. I don't think people like these two would risk their considerable reputations publishing something that every one of their peers could take apart at a cocktail party. More likely, there's more behind this website. HN readers rarely give that obvious benefit of the doubt.