3 ms·
All of these score 1 on one of my favorite HN comments, the Yudkowski Ambition Scale[0]. That's OK, but it's a bit disappointing for a post that clearly tries t
by skrebbel 12y ago
All of these score 1 on one of my favorite HN comments, the Yudkowski Ambition Scale[0]. That's OK, but it's a bit disappointing for a post that clearly tries to come off as visionary.
[0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4510702 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4510702
- caseyohara 12y agoYou're right that none of these ideas are ambitious, but that's exactly the point. The list is "Things I still can't do in November 2014".
- skrebbel 12y agoYeah ok. I must've not had my coffee yet.
- netcan 12y agoThese are both kind of like brainstorming tools, ways of thinking about ideas. Your tool encourages one to aggrandise an idea, which can be useful. This encourages trivialisation an idea, which can be useful too. I think doing both at the same time is a sort of essential entrepreneurial doublethink. Ideas, products, inventions and such are surprisingly (very surprisingly, to me) hard to place on that Yudkowski Ambition Scale. The line between trivial and revolutionary is surprisingly blurry. I think one could argue or tweak several of these to be in the 2-5/6 range. At least they could to the extent that they can be argue to be a 1. 1. Get a blood test simply, myself, without going to a lab, and get the results overnight. If you extend this past just bloods, combine this with DIY diagnostics tools, 23andme, items 5, 16, 31... I'm sure you can arrive at a sort of preventative medicine something something new paradigm. A Yudkowski 3? 2. Build a house myself using standard small interchangeable parts like legos. Revolutionize town and cityscapes, quarter the cost of our single biggest purchase.... Yudkowski 3, I think. Even Yudkowski's 1 & 2 could arguably be 3-5s.
- eli_gottlieb 12y agoThat's hysterical! I like how the transhuman stuff starts at (6), the potential existential risks at (7), and by the time you get to (10) you're literally more ambitious than God. Of course, there needs to be an analogous scale for controlling the outcomes of developing anything that ambitious. And a choir that you can hire to follow you around singing the necessary Ominous Latin Chanting while you announce your ambition levels.
- GFK_of_xmaspast 12y agoI don't know, if 1 is "well adjusted normal human being" and 10 is "Yudkowski", this guy is weird and creepy enough to be probably about a 6 or so.