4 ms·
Couple of warning signs: (1) Article is actually a paid advertisement, and doesn't pretend to anything like peer review. (2) "In addition to the statistical e
by ajarmst 12y ago
Couple of warning signs: (1) Article is actually a paid advertisement, and doesn't pretend to anything like peer review. (2) "In addition to the statistical evidence, Renshaw collected anecdotes that supported his developing theory." Seriously?
As we don't have anything like a useful theory of what depression is and the details of how neurotransmitter levels are connected to mood, especially over the long term, he's really jumping to conclusions. His statistical correlation is weak, and correlates to a lot of other things (maybe Republicans cause suicide, or proximity to harbors protects you from suicide). He needs a causal mechanism and a LOT better data before this is anything like a useful hypothesis. By the way - lets note that Switzerland's suicide rate is considerably lower that France, and half that of Japan (most of whose population centers are near sea level).
- ajarmst 12y agoAddendum: I also note that Pakistan, Peru and Nepal report very low suicide rates versus world averages. Usual questions about what "report" means, but one would probably think they would discuss this apparent problem with their theory.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]