3 ms·
> Bob's photon does NOT change state as a result of Alice's measurement. It is in exactly the same state that it was in before: entangled, which is to say, if y
by jessriedel 12y ago
> Bob's photon does NOT change state as a result of Alice's measurement. It is in exactly the same state that it was in before: entangled, which is to say, if you consider it in isolation, it is in a quantum mixed state. NOTHING changes on Bob's side as a result of Alice's measurement.
As usual in these situations, it depends on being precise about what one is referring to with words like "state". But with the common definition -- a density matrix updated to incorporate all macroscopic data -- the state of A certainly does change following the measurement of B. It goes from fully mixed to pure.
Of course, Bob's personal epistemic state (which doesn't include data that he hasn't yet received from Alive) doesn't change.
You can try to say that Alice and Bob's photons have merely become entangled with the measuring apparatus, or some similar many-worlds-type statement, but then you'd be using "state" in a very different way than the vast majority of experimental physicists. You might think that definition better fitting with reality, but it certainly wouldn't make the NASA press release wrong.
- lisper 12y agoIt's more than Bob's personal epistemic state that doesn't change. The physical state of his photon doesn't change either. The change from "fully mixed" to "pure" is a change in the mathematical representation of the situation, not a change in Bob's local physical reality. There is no experiment Bob can perform on his photon that will reveal to him whether or not Alice has measured her photon or not (note that this remains true EVEN AFTER he has received Alice's bits). The difference between a mixed and a pure state is simply a difference in mathematical perspective, not a difference in the underlying physical reality.
- jessriedel 12y agoI'm well aware of the physics of the situation. It's my day job. I'm just telling you that NASA hasn't said anything false. The common meaning of "the state of the photon" is exactly as I described above, and it certainly does change. Your discussion of "underlying reality" is besides my point, since those words don't appear in the original article. > There is no experiment Bob can perform on his photon that will reveal to him whether or not Alice has measured her photon or not (note that this remains true EVEN AFTER he has received Alice's bits). I'm not sure what you mean here, but a reasonable interpretation of your words would be false. You consider a situation where Bob has received bits from Alice even when she might not have actually made a measurement. If so then I guess you're saying that Alice just makes these up? If so, then Bob can certainly check to see if Alice has actually made the measurement she claims to have by making a local measurement on his photon, and this can result in an outcome that lets Bob definitively determine that Alice is lying to him. [Of course, sometimes Bob's result agrees with Alice's claimed bits; in this case, Alice has simply guessed correctly for what she will end up receiving in her (now fully determined) experiment.]
- lisper 12y ago> I'm well aware of the physics of the situation. It's my day job. I have met many people for whom this is their day job who nonetheless don't understand this. > Bob can certainly check to see if Alice has actually made the measurement she claims to have by making a local measurement on his photon No, he can't. The best he can do is determine (probabilistically) that the bits Alice gave him are not the result of such a measurement. But he cannot know whether or not Alice's measurement was actually performed. In other words, Bob cannot distinguish: 1. Alice does not perform a measurement, but rather simply pulls two bits out of a hat. 2. Alice does perform the measurement, but sends Bob two bits pulled out of a hat rather than the results of her measurement. He cannot make this determination EVEN PROBABILISTICALLY, i.e. after aggregating many trials all prepared the same way. Because of this, it is wrong to say that Alice's measurement changed the state of Bob's photon. Of course, Bob can distinguish between Alice sending him bits pulled out of a hat and bits resulting from her measurement, in which case he can know that Alice must have performed the measurement. But that's a red herring.
- jessriedel 12y agoAgain, I promise you I understand the physics as well or better than you. So start by presuming that any disagreement we have is from miscommunication, not me being an idiot, and go easy on the all caps. The misunderstanding you're now addressing arose because it doesn't make sense for you to say "this remains true EVEN AFTER he has received Alice's bits" if you're describing a situation where Alice is always making up the data. (Why would Bob ever look at it if it's always made up? It has nothing to do with the rest of the problem.) With your clarification, I know understand what you mean by determining "whether or not Alice has measured her photon or not... EVEN AFTER he has received Alice's bits". But this doesn't change my previous comments on the common definition of "state".
- lisper 12y ago> Again, I promise you I understand the physics as well or better than you. That's certainly possible, but I wouldn't take it as a foregone conclusion. Nonetheless, I apologize if I came across as strident. > Why would Bob ever look at it if it's always made up? Why would he not? He doesn't know whether or not the bits are made up. Let's call them "corrupted" because it doesn't have to be intentional duplicity on Alice's part. It could be simple experimental error, or a noisy communications channel, or a MITM attack. None of these are distinguishable by Bob from Alice having not made a measurement. In any event, Bob might look because he wants to determine if the bits are corrupted. Or he might look because he thinks he's participating in the quantum teleportation protocol, notwithstanding that he's actually not because the bits are corrupted. Note that for any given bit pair he has to choose one or the other: teleport, or check for corruption. He can't do both. It is also worth noting that even the possibility of corruption is enough to debunk the idea that Alice's measurement results in a physical change on Bob's side. Bob can tell (probabilistically) that there is corruption happening, and he can put a probabilistic upper bound on the amount of corruption that is happening, but under no circumstances can he tell which measurements are corrupted and which are not. One in four corrupted measurements will appear to be genuine by pure chance, and there's no way for Bob to know, even probabilistically, which is which.